Caceres Billy A, Brody Abraham, Luscombe Rachel E, Primiano Jillian E, Marusca Peter, Sitts Edward M, Chyun Deborah
All the authors are with the Rory Meyers College of Nursing, New York University, New York, NY.
Am J Public Health. 2017 Apr;107(4):e13-e21. doi: 10.2105/AJPH.2016.303630. Epub 2017 Feb 16.
Mental health and HIV disparities are well documented among sexual minorities, but there is a dearth of research on other chronic conditions. Cardiovascular disease remains the leading cause of death worldwide. Although sexual minorities have high rates of several modifiable risk factors for cardiovascular disease (including stress, tobacco use, and alcohol consumption), there is a paucity of research in this area.
In this systematic review, we synthesized and critiqued the existing evidence on cardiovascular disease among sexual minority adults.
We conducted a thorough literature search of 6 electronic databases for studies published between January 1985 and December 2015 that compared cardiovascular disease risk or prevalence between sexual minority and heterosexual adults.
We included peer-reviewed English-language studies that compared cardiovascular disease risk or diagnoses between sexual minority and heterosexual individuals older than 18 years. We excluded reviews, case studies, and gray literature. A total of 31 studies met inclusion criteria.
At least 2 authors independently abstracted data from each study. We performed quality assessment of retrieved studies using the Crowe Critical Appraisal Tool.
Sexual minority women exhibited greater cardiovascular disease risk related to tobacco use, alcohol consumption, illicit drug use, poor mental health, and body mass index, whereas sexual minority men experienced excess risk related to tobacco use, illicit drug use, and poor mental health. We identified several limitations in the extant literature. The majority of included studies were cross-sectional analyses that used self-reported measures of cardiovascular disease. Even though we observed elevated cardiovascular disease risk, we found few differences in cardiovascular disease diagnoses (including hypertension, diabetes, and high cholesterol). Overall, 23 of the 26 studies that examined cardiovascular disease diagnoses used subjective measures. Only 7 studies used a combination of biomarkers and self-report measures to establish cardiovascular disease risk and diagnoses.
AUTHORS' CONCLUSIONS: Social conditions appear to exert a negative effect on cardiovascular disease risk among sexual minorities. Although we found few differences in cardiovascular disease diagnoses, we identified an elevated risk for cardiovascular disease in both sexual minority men and women. There is a need for research that incorporates subjective and objective measures of cardiovascular disease risk. Public Health Implications: Cardiovascular disease is a major health concern for clinicians, public health practitioners, and policymakers. This systematic review supports the need for culturally appropriate interventions that address cardiovascular disease risk in sexual minority adults.
性少数群体中心理健康与艾滋病毒差异已有充分记录,但针对其他慢性病的研究却很匮乏。心血管疾病仍是全球主要死因。尽管性少数群体中几种可改变的心血管疾病风险因素(包括压力、吸烟和饮酒)发生率较高,但该领域研究仍很匮乏。
在本系统评价中,我们综合并批判性地审视了关于成年性少数群体中心血管疾病的现有证据。
我们对6个电子数据库进行了全面的文献检索,以查找1985年1月至2015年12月期间发表的比较性少数群体与异性恋成年人心血管疾病风险或患病率的研究。
我们纳入了比较18岁以上性少数群体与异性恋个体心血管疾病风险或诊断情况的经同行评审的英文研究。我们排除了综述、病例研究和灰色文献。共有31项研究符合纳入标准。
至少2名作者独立从每项研究中提取数据。我们使用克罗伊批判性评价工具对检索到的研究进行质量评估。
性少数群体女性在吸烟、饮酒、使用非法药物、心理健康状况不佳和体重指数方面表现出更高的心血管疾病风险,而性少数群体男性在吸烟、使用非法药物和心理健康状况不佳方面存在额外风险。我们在现有文献中发现了几个局限性。纳入的大多数研究是横断面分析,使用自我报告的心血管疾病测量方法。尽管我们观察到心血管疾病风险升高,但我们发现心血管疾病诊断(包括高血压、糖尿病和高胆固醇)方面差异不大。总体而言,在26项检查心血管疾病诊断的研究中,有23项使用主观测量方法。只有7项研究使用生物标志物和自我报告测量方法相结合来确定心血管疾病风险和诊断。
社会状况似乎对性少数群体的心血管疾病风险产生负面影响。尽管我们发现心血管疾病诊断方面差异不大,但我们确定性少数群体男性和女性的心血管疾病风险均有所升高。需要开展纳入心血管疾病风险主观和客观测量方法的研究。对公共卫生的影响:心血管疾病是临床医生、公共卫生从业者和政策制定者主要关注的健康问题。本系统评价支持需要采取适合文化背景的干预措施来解决成年性少数群体的心血管疾病风险。