Department of Genetics, Evolution and Environment, University College London, Darwin Building 218A, Gower Street, London WC1E 6BT, UK.
Department of Earth Sciences, University College London, London, UK.
Evol Dev. 2017 Mar;19(2):85-95. doi: 10.1111/ede.12218. Epub 2017 Feb 17.
Morphological integration and modularity, which describe the relationships among morphological attributes and reflect genetic, developmental, and functional interactions, have been hypothesized to be major influences on trait responses to selection and thus morphological evolution. The mammalian presacral vertebral column shows little variation in vertebral count and therefore specialization for function occurs primarily through modification of vertebral shape. However, vertebral shape has been suggested to be under strong control from developmental canalization, although this has never been explicitly tested. Here, we assess hypotheses of developmental modules in the vertebrae of felids to determine whether developmental interactions are a primary influence on vertebral modularity. Additionally, we analyze the magnitudes of both intravertebral integration and disparity to evaluate if level of integration varies along the vertebral column and, if so, whether integration and disparity are associated. Our results confirm the hypothesis of vertebral developmental modularity, with most presacral vertebrae displaying two modules. Exceptions are concentrated in the boundaries among traditional and functional regions, suggesting that intravertebral modularity may reflect larger-scale modularity of the felid vertebral column. We further demonstrate that overall integration and disparity are highest in posterior vertebrae, thus providing an empirical example of integration potentially promoting greater morphological responses to selection.
形态整合和形态模块化,描述了形态特征之间的关系,反映了遗传、发育和功能的相互作用,被假设为对特征对选择的反应以及形态进化的主要影响。哺乳动物的荐前脊柱在椎骨数量上变化很小,因此功能的专业化主要通过改变椎骨的形状来实现。然而,尽管这从未被明确测试过,但有人认为椎骨形状受到发育通道的强烈控制。在这里,我们评估了猫科动物椎体的发育模块假说,以确定发育相互作用是否是椎骨模块化的主要影响因素。此外,我们分析了椎骨内整合和差异的幅度,以评估整合水平是否沿脊柱变化,如果是,整合和差异是否相关。我们的结果证实了椎体发育模块化的假说,大多数荐前椎骨显示出两个模块。例外情况主要集中在传统和功能区域之间的边界,这表明椎骨内模块化可能反映了猫科动物脊柱的更大规模模块化。我们进一步证明,整体整合和差异在后部椎骨中最高,从而为整合可能促进对选择的更大形态反应提供了一个经验实例。