Merianos Ashley L, Gittens Olivia E, Mahabee-Gittens E Melinda
School of Human Services; University of Cincinnati; Cincinnati, OH.
William Mason High School; Mason, OH.
J Subst Use. 2016;21(6):614-619. doi: 10.3109/14659891.2015.1118565. Epub 2016 May 9.
This study was conducted to assess the quantity, quality, and reach of e-cigarette health effects YouTube videos, and to quantify the description of positive and negative e-cigarette health effects and promotional content in each video.
Searches for videos were conducted in 2015 using the YouTube search engine, and the top 20 search results by relevance and view count were identified. Videos were classified by educational/medical news, advertising/marketing, and personal/testimonial categories. A coding sheet was used to assess the presence or absence of negative and positive health effects, and promotional content.
Of the 320 videos retrieved, only 55 unique videos were included. The majority of videos (46.9%) were educational/medical/news, 29.7% were personal/testimonial, and 23.4% were advertising/marketing. The three most common negative health effects included discussing nicotine, e-cigarettes not being FDA regulated, and known and unknown health consequences related to e-cigarette use. The top positive health effects discussed were how e-cigarettes can help individuals quit smoking, e-cigarettes are healthier than smoking, and e-cigarettes have no smoke or secondhand smoke exposure.
It is critical to monitor YouTube health effects content and develop appropriate messages to inform consumers about the risks associated with use while mitigating misleading information presented.
本研究旨在评估YouTube上电子烟健康影响相关视频的数量、质量及传播范围,并量化每个视频中关于电子烟健康影响的正面和负面描述以及宣传内容。
2015年使用YouTube搜索引擎搜索视频,根据相关性和观看次数确定排名前20的搜索结果。视频分为教育/医学新闻、广告/营销和个人/推荐三类。使用编码表评估负面和正面健康影响以及宣传内容的有无。
在检索到的320个视频中,仅纳入了55个独特的视频。大多数视频(46.9%)为教育/医学/新闻类,29.7%为个人/推荐类,23.4%为广告/营销类。最常见的三种负面健康影响包括讨论尼古丁、电子烟不受美国食品药品监督管理局监管以及与使用电子烟相关的已知和未知健康后果。所讨论的最主要正面健康影响是电子烟如何帮助个人戒烟、电子烟比吸烟更健康以及电子烟无烟雾或二手烟暴露。
监测YouTube上的健康影响内容并制定适当信息,以便在减少误导性信息的同时告知消费者与使用相关的风险至关重要。