Sears Clara G, Walker Kandi L, Hart Joy L, Lee Alexander S, Siu Allison, Smith Courteney
University of Louisville, United States.
Tob Prev Cessat. 2017 Apr;3. doi: 10.18332/tpc/69393. Epub 2017 Apr 7.
Videos promoting electronic cigarettes (e-cigarettes) can be easily accessed on YouTube. Marketing claims present in YouTube videos may help shape the public's opinion of e-cigarettes. Thus, it is important to understand the most frequent marketing claims and video sources.
The objectives of this study were to 1) identify marketing claims in YouTube videos that are commonly made on e-cigarette retail websites and 2) compare the frequency of marketing claims in user-generated and professional YouTube videos. Through content analysis, this study evaluated six marketing claims and descriptive information about YouTube videos (n = 50) related to "electronic cigarettes" and "vape".
Overall, the most frequent marketing claim promoted e-cigarette use as better than traditional tobacco use (52%). Approximately 65% of videos appeared to be user-generated and 35% were professionally-produced. Compared to user-generated videos, significantly more professional videos made claims that e-cigarettes are cleaner (p < 0.001) and cheaper (p = 0.04) than traditional cigarettes. Additionally, more professional videos had claims promoting e-cigarettes as better than traditional cigarettes because of their convenience-the user can smoke anywhere (p < 0.0001) and the products do not produce secondhand smoke (p < 0.001). The most frequent claim in user-generated videos was related to recreation (53%).
Videos on YouTube promote e-cigarettes as safer than other tobacco products. Videos appearing to be user-generated contained different marketing claims compared to professional videos. Further research is necessary to assess how the perceived source of the video impacts the ways these marketing claims shape public perception and influence use.
在YouTube上可以轻松获取宣传电子烟的视频。YouTube视频中出现的营销主张可能有助于塑造公众对电子烟的看法。因此,了解最常见的营销主张和视频来源很重要。
本研究的目的是:1)识别YouTube视频中常见于电子烟零售网站的营销主张;2)比较用户生成的YouTube视频和专业YouTube视频中营销主张的出现频率。通过内容分析,本研究评估了与“电子烟”和“蒸汽烟”相关的六个营销主张以及关于YouTube视频(n = 50)的描述性信息。
总体而言,最常见的营销主张是宣传使用电子烟比使用传统烟草更好(52%)。大约65%的视频似乎是用户生成的,35%是专业制作的。与用户生成的视频相比,明显更多的专业视频声称电子烟比传统香烟更清洁(p < 0.001)且更便宜(p = 0.04)。此外,更多专业视频声称由于电子烟方便——用户可以在任何地方吸烟(p < 0.0001)且产品不会产生二手烟(p < 0.001),所以电子烟比传统香烟更好。用户生成的视频中最常见的主张与娱乐有关(53%)。
YouTube上的视频宣传电子烟比其他烟草产品更安全。与专业视频相比,看似用户生成的视频包含不同的营销主张。有必要进行进一步研究,以评估视频的感知来源如何影响这些营销主张塑造公众认知和影响使用的方式。