Romano Andrew M, Gade Kristine E, Nielsen Gradon, Havard Robert, Harrison James H, Barclay Josh, Stukenborg George J, Read Paul W, Blackhall Leslie J, Dillon Patrick M
Department of Medicine.
Department of Medicine, University of Rochester, Rochester, New York, USA.
Oncologist. 2017 Mar;22(3):318-323. doi: 10.1634/theoncologist.2016-0227. Epub 2017 Feb 20.
Early palliative care for advanced cancer patients improves quality of life and survival, but less is known about its effect on intensive care unit (ICU) use at the end of life. This analysis assessed the effect of a comprehensive early palliative care program on ICU use and other outcomes among patients with advanced cancer.
A retrospective cohort of patients with advanced cancer enrolled in an early palliative care program ( = 275) was compared with a concurrent control group of patients receiving standard care ( = 195) during the same time period by using multivariable logistic regression analysis. The multidisciplinary outpatient palliative care program used early end-of-life care planning, weekly interdisciplinary meetings to discuss patient status, and patient-reported outcomes assessment integrated within the electronic health record.
Patients in the control group had statistically significantly higher likelihood of ICU admission at the end of life (odds ratios [ORs]: last 6 months, 3.07; last month, 3.59; terminal admission, 4.69), higher likelihood of death in the hospital (OR, 4.14) or ICU (OR, 5.57), and lower likelihood of hospice enrollment (OR, 0.13). Use of chemotherapy or radiation did not significantly differ between groups, nor did length of ICU stay, code status, ICU procedures (other than cardiopulmonary resuscitation), disposition location, and outcomes after ICU admission.
Early palliative care significantly reduced ICU use at the end of life but did not change ICU events. This study supports early initiation of palliative care for advanced cancer patients before hospitalizations and intensive care. 2017;22:318-323 IMPLICATIONS FOR PRACTICE: Palliative care has shown clear benefit in quality of life and survival in advanced cancer patients, but less is known about its effect on intensive care. This retrospective cohort study at a university hospital showed that in the last 6 months of life, palliative care significantly reduced intensive care unit (ICU) and hospital admissions, reduced deaths in the hospital, and increased hospice enrollment. It did not, however, change patients' experiences within the ICU, such as number of procedures, code status, length of stay, or disposition. The findings further support that palliative care exerts its benefit before, rather than during, the ICU setting.
晚期癌症患者的早期姑息治疗可改善生活质量并延长生存期,但对于其对临终时重症监护病房(ICU)使用情况的影响却知之甚少。本分析评估了一项综合性早期姑息治疗方案对晚期癌症患者ICU使用情况及其他结局的影响。
采用多变量逻辑回归分析,将纳入早期姑息治疗方案的晚期癌症患者回顾性队列(n = 275)与同期接受标准治疗的对照患者组(n = 195)进行比较。多学科门诊姑息治疗方案采用早期临终关怀规划、每周跨学科会议以讨论患者状况,以及整合在电子健康记录中的患者报告结局评估。
对照组患者在临终时入住ICU的可能性在统计学上显著更高(比值比[OR]:最后6个月,3.07;最后1个月,3.59;临终入院,4.69),在医院死亡(OR,4.14)或在ICU死亡(OR,5.57)的可能性更高,而入住临终关怀机构的可能性更低(OR,0.13)。两组之间化疗或放疗的使用情况、ICU住院时间、代码状态、ICU操作(心肺复苏除外)、出院地点以及ICU入院后的结局并无显著差异。
早期姑息治疗显著减少了临终时的ICU使用,但未改变ICU事件。本研究支持在晚期癌症患者住院和进入重症监护之前尽早启动姑息治疗。2017年;22:318 - 323 对实践的启示:姑息治疗已在晚期癌症患者的生活质量和生存期方面显示出明显益处,但对于其对重症监护影响的了解较少。这项在大学医院进行的回顾性队列研究表明,在生命的最后6个月,姑息治疗显著减少了重症监护病房(ICU)和医院入院次数,降低了医院内的死亡人数,并增加了临终关怀机构的入住率。然而,它并未改变患者在ICU内的经历,如操作次数、代码状态、住院时间或出院地点。这些发现进一步支持姑息治疗在ICU环境之前而非期间发挥其益处。