Duane Frances, Aznar Marianne C, Bartlett Freddie, Cutter David J, Darby Sarah C, Jagsi Reshma, Lorenzen Ebbe L, McArdle Orla, McGale Paul, Myerson Saul, Rahimi Kazem, Vivekanandan Sindu, Warren Samantha, Taylor Carolyn W
Clinical Trial Service Unit, Nuffield Department of Population Health, University of Oxford, UK; Medical Research Council Population Health Research Unit, Nuffield Department of Population Health, University of Oxford, UK.
Clinical Trial Service Unit, Nuffield Department of Population Health, University of Oxford, UK.
Radiother Oncol. 2017 Mar;122(3):416-422. doi: 10.1016/j.radonc.2017.01.008. Epub 2017 Feb 21.
The heart is a complex anatomical organ and contouring the cardiac substructures is challenging. This study presents a reproducible method for contouring left ventricular and coronary arterial segments on radiotherapy CT-planning scans.
Segments were defined from cardiology models and agreed by two cardiologists. Reference atlas contours were delineated and written guidelines prepared. Six radiation oncologists tested the atlas. Spatial variation was assessed using the DICE similarity coefficient (DSC) and the directed Hausdorff average distance (d→). The effect of spatial variation on doses was assessed using six different breast cancer regimens.
The atlas enabled contouring of 15 cardiac segments. Inter-observer contour overlap (mean DSC) was 0.60-0.73 for five left ventricular segments and 0.10-0.53 for ten coronary arterial segments. Inter-observer contour separation (mean d→) was 1.5-2.2mm for left ventricular segments and 1.3-5.1mm for coronary artery segments. This spatial variation resulted in <1Gy dose variation for most regimens and segments, but 1.2-21.8Gy variation for segments close to a field edge.
This cardiac atlas enables reproducible contouring of segments of the left ventricle and main coronary arteries to facilitate future studies relating cardiac radiation doses to clinical outcomes.
心脏是一个复杂的解剖器官,勾勒心脏亚结构具有挑战性。本研究提出了一种在放射治疗CT计划扫描上勾勒左心室和冠状动脉节段的可重复方法。
节段由心脏病学模型定义,并经两位心脏病专家认可。绘制参考图谱轮廓并制定书面指南。六位放射肿瘤学家对该图谱进行了测试。使用DICE相似系数(DSC)和定向豪斯多夫平均距离(d→)评估空间变异性。使用六种不同的乳腺癌治疗方案评估空间变异性对剂量的影响。
该图谱能够勾勒出15个心脏节段。五位左心室节段的观察者间轮廓重叠(平均DSC)为0.60 - 0.73,十个冠状动脉节段为0.10 - 0.53。左心室节段的观察者间轮廓分离(平均d→)为1.5 - 2.2毫米,冠状动脉节段为1.3 - 5.1毫米。这种空间变异性导致大多数治疗方案和节段的剂量变化<1 Gy,但靠近射野边缘的节段剂量变化为1.2 - 21.8 Gy。
该心脏图谱能够对左心室和主要冠状动脉节段进行可重复的轮廓勾勒,以促进未来将心脏辐射剂量与临床结果相关联的研究。