Kern Mark K, Balasubramanian Gokulakrishnan, Sanvanson Patrick, Agrawal Dilpesh, Wuerl Ashley, Shaker Reza
Division of Gastroenterology and Hepatology, Medical College of Wisconsin, Milwaukee, Wisconsin.
Division of Gastroenterology and Hepatology, Medical College of Wisconsin, Milwaukee, Wisconsin
Am J Physiol Gastrointest Liver Physiol. 2017 May 1;312(5):G516-G525. doi: 10.1152/ajpgi.00382.2016. Epub 2017 Mar 2.
The present understanding of pharyngeal motor function remains incomplete. Among the remaining gaps of knowledge in this regard is the magnitude of variability of pharyngeal peristaltic pressure amplitude. Although variability can pose difficulty in interpretation of manometric findings, its magnitude can inform the operational range and reserve of the pharyngeal contractile function. We aimed to define the intra- and intersubject and intersession variability of select pharyngeal manometric parameters and, using this information, determine the number of swallow repetitions for acquiring reliable pharyngeal manometric data. We recorded pharyngeal peristalsis in 10 healthy subjects (age: 50 ± 25 yr, 5 women) by high-resolution manometry during two separate sessions of 20 sequences of 0.5-ml water swallows. Two-way ANOVA showed significant variation in the mean peak peristaltic pressure value across sites ( < 0.0001) as well as within the data at each site ( < 0.0001). Similarly, the pharyngeal contractile integral exhibited significant inter- ( = 0.003) and intrasubject ( < 0.001) variability. The Shapiro-Wilk normality test showed mixed results, in that some sites showed normally distributed data, whereas others did not. A robust Monte Carlo simulation showed that the nominal sample size was different for various tested metrics. For a power of 0.8, commonly accepted as an adequate threshold for acceptable statistical power, the optimal sample size for various peristaltic parameters ranged between 3 and 15. There is significant intra- and intersubject variability in site-specific and integrated parameters of pharyngeal peristalsis. The observed variance indicates a significant operational range and reserve in pharyngeal contractile function while necessitating parameter-specific sample size for reliable results. Intra- and intersubject variability are significant and different at various sites within the contractile pharynx. In addition, significant swallow-to-swallow and subject-to-subject variability exists in pharyngeal contractile integral. The range of intrasubject variability indicates the existence of broad operational range and reserve. Lastly, our variability studies informed Monte Carlo and power analyses, yielding estimates of sample size that would ensure accurate representation of pressure metric variability.
目前对咽运动功能的理解仍不完整。在这方面尚存的知识空白中,有咽蠕动压力幅度的变异性大小。尽管变异性会给测压结果的解读带来困难,但其大小可以反映咽收缩功能的工作范围和储备能力。我们旨在确定选定的咽测压参数在受试者内和受试者间以及不同测试时段的变异性,并利用这些信息确定获取可靠咽测压数据所需的吞咽重复次数。我们通过高分辨率测压法,在两个独立的时段中,让10名健康受试者(年龄:50±25岁,5名女性)进行20组0.5毫升水吞咽序列,记录咽蠕动情况。双向方差分析显示,各部位平均蠕动峰值压力值存在显著差异(<0.0001),且每个部位的数据内部也存在显著差异(<0.0001)。同样,咽收缩积分在受试者间(=0.003)和受试者内(<0.001)均表现出显著变异性。夏皮罗-威尔克正态性检验结果不一,即有些部位的数据呈正态分布,而有些则不然。一个稳健的蒙特卡洛模拟表明,不同测试指标的名义样本量不同。对于通常被认为是可接受统计效力的适当阈值的0.8的效力,各种蠕动参数的最佳样本量在3至15之间。咽蠕动的特定部位和综合参数在受试者内和受试者间存在显著变异性。观察到的方差表明咽收缩功能有显著的工作范围和储备能力,同时为获得可靠结果需要特定参数的样本量。在收缩性咽内的不同部位,受试者内和受试者间变异性显著且不同。此外,咽收缩积分在吞咽之间和受试者之间存在显著变异性。受试者内变异性的范围表明存在广泛的工作范围和储备能力。最后,我们的变异性研究为蒙特卡洛模拟和效力分析提供了信息,得出了能确保准确反映压力指标变异性的样本量估计值。