So Jae In, Song Dae Heon, Park Joo Hyun, Choi Eunseok, Yoon Jung Yoon, Yoo Yeonji, Chung Myung Eun
Department of Rehabilitation Medicine, St. Paul's Hospital, College of Medicine, The Catholic University of Korea, Seoul, Korea.
Ann Rehabil Med. 2017 Feb;41(1):51-57. doi: 10.5535/arm.2017.41.1.51. Epub 2017 Feb 28.
To compare the accuracy of ultrasound (US)-guided and non-US-guided botulinum toxin (BTX) injection into the salivary glands (parotid and submandibular glands) of cadavers.
Two rehabilitation physician injected dye into three sites in the salivary glands (two sites in the parotid gland and one site in the submandibular gland) on one side of each cadaver (one was injected on the right side, while the other was injected on the left side), using either a non-US-guided injection procedure based on superficial landmarks or a US-guided procedure. Orange dye was used for the US-guided procedure, and green dye was used for the blind procedure. Two physicians uninvolved with the injection procedures and who were blinded to the method of injection dissected the cadavers to identify whether the dye was accurately injected into each target site.
The accuracies of the blind and US-guided injections into the parotid gland were 79.17% and 95.83%, respectively. In the submandibular gland, the accuracies of the blind and US-guided injections were 50.00% and 91.67%, respectively. The difference in accuracy between the two procedures was statistically significant only in the submandibular gland (p=0.025). There were no significant differences in the accuracy of US-guided and non-US-guided injections between the two physicians for the two sites in the parotid gland (p=0.278 and p=0.146, respectively).
US-guided BTX injection into the submandibular gland offers significantly greater accuracy over blind injection. For the treatment of drooling by injecting BTX into the submandibular gland, clinicians should consider using US guidance for improved accuracy.
比较超声(US)引导下和非US引导下向尸体唾液腺(腮腺和颌下腺)注射肉毒杆菌毒素(BTX)的准确性。
两名康复医师在每具尸体的一侧唾液腺的三个部位(腮腺两个部位,颌下腺一个部位)注射染料(一具尸体右侧注射,另一具尸体左侧注射),采用基于体表标志的非US引导注射方法或US引导方法。US引导注射用橙色染料,盲法注射用绿色染料。两名未参与注射过程且对注射方法不知情的医师解剖尸体,以确定染料是否准确注射到每个目标部位。
腮腺盲法注射和US引导注射的准确率分别为79.17%和95.83%。在颌下腺,盲法注射和US引导注射的准确率分别为50.00%和91.67%。两种方法的准确率差异仅在颌下腺有统计学意义(p = 0.025)。两位医师在腮腺两个部位的US引导注射和非US引导注射准确率之间无显著差异(分别为p = 0.278和p = 0.146)。
US引导下向颌下腺注射BTX比盲法注射的准确性显著更高。对于通过向颌下腺注射BTX治疗流涎,临床医生应考虑使用US引导以提高准确性。