Hassan Tariq, Tran Tanya, Doan Nam, Mazhar Mir, Bajaj Neeraj, Munshi Tariq, Galbraith Niall, Groll Dianne
Department of Psychiatry, Queen's University.
Department of Psychology, Queen's University.
Can Med Educ J. 2016 Oct 18;7(2):e14-e24. eCollection 2016 Oct.
The medical culture is defined by mental illness stigma, non-disclosure, and avoidance of professional treatment. Little research has explored attitudes and help-seeking behaviors of psychiatry trainees if they were to become mentally ill.
Psychiatry residents ( = 106) from training centres across Ontario, Canada completed a postal survey on their attitudes, barriers to disclosure, and help-seeking preferences in the context of hypothetically becoming mentally ill.
Thirty-three percent of respondents reported personal history of mental illness and the frequency of mental illness by year of training did not significantly differ. The most popular first contact for disclosure of mental illness was family and friends ( = 61, 57.5%). Frequent barriers to disclosure included career implications ( = , 36.8%), stigma ( = 11, 10.4%), and professional standing ( = 15, 14.2%). Personal history of mental illness was the only factor associated with in-patient treatment choice, with those with history opting for more formal advice versus informal advice.
At the level of residency training, psychiatrists are reporting barriers to disclosure and help-seeking if they were to experience mental illness. A majority of psychiatry residents would only disclose to informal supports. Those with a history of mental illness would prefer formal treatment services over informal services.
医学文化存在精神疾病污名化、不披露病情以及回避专业治疗的现象。很少有研究探讨精神科住院医师如果自己患上精神疾病时的态度和求助行为。
来自加拿大安大略省各培训中心的106名精神科住院医师完成了一项邮寄调查,内容涉及他们在假设自己患上精神疾病情况下的态度、披露病情的障碍以及求助偏好。
33%的受访者报告有精神疾病个人史,且按培训年份划分的精神疾病发病频率无显著差异。披露精神疾病时最常联系的对象是家人和朋友(61人,占57.5%)。常见的披露障碍包括对职业的影响(……人,占36.8%)、污名化(11人,占10.4%)以及职业地位(15人,占14.2%)。精神疾病个人史是与住院治疗选择相关的唯一因素,有精神疾病史的人更倾向于寻求正式建议而非非正式建议。
在住院医师培训阶段,精神科医生表示如果自己患上精神疾病,在披露病情和寻求帮助方面存在障碍。大多数精神科住院医师只会向非正式支持对象披露病情。有精神疾病史的人相对于非正式服务而言更倾向于正式治疗服务。