Bromage Sabri, Chung Holly Ya-Fan, Bonville Hannah, Sprenger Jeannie Choi, Lander Rebecca, Ganmaa Davaasambuu
1 Department of Nutrition, Harvard TH Chan School of Public Health, Boston, MA, USA.
2 Department of Nutrition, Food Security and Livelihoods, International Medical Corps, Washington, DC, USA.
Food Nutr Bull. 2017 Jun;38(2):267-272. doi: 10.1177/0379572117700749. Epub 2017 Mar 30.
Population-based dietary assessment is important for informing national nutrition policy. The developing country setting presents challenges for robust implementation of dietary surveys, yet effective nutrition interventions are often urgently required.
To develop and evaluate a low-cost approach to epidemiologic dietary assessment in Mongolia, involving the use of large cohorts of local public health and medical students as research assistants for collecting diet records.
From 2011 to 2016, over 200 Mongolian medical and public health university students were trained to collect paired summer and winter 3-day weighed diet records from urban and rural study populations across the geographic expanse of Mongolia. Students were supervised during data collection, and their performance and experience during training and data collection were qualitatively evaluated from their own perspectives as well as those of the investigators.
Students collected detailed and thorough diet records and generally reported positive feedback regarding training and data collection. Frequent supervision of students during data collection proved to be extremely worthwhile. While rural participants were amenable to having students follow them, students faced several challenges in assessing the diets of urban participants. These challenges may best be addressed by separately training these participants beforehand.
With adequate training and supervision, university students may be a useful and cost-effective resource for large-scale dietary surveys in regions where their use would be practical and culturally appropriate. Further research is warranted to study how well this approach may be adapted outside Mongolia and to other dietary assessment methods and technologies.
基于人群的膳食评估对于制定国家营养政策至关重要。在发展中国家开展膳食调查面临诸多挑战,但往往又迫切需要有效的营养干预措施。
在蒙古开发并评估一种低成本的流行病学膳食评估方法,即利用大量当地公共卫生和医学生作为研究助手来收集饮食记录。
2011年至2016年期间,200多名蒙古医科和公共卫生专业大学生接受培训,从蒙古各地城乡研究人群中收集夏季和冬季为期3天的成对称重饮食记录。在数据收集过程中对学生进行监督,并从学生自身以及研究人员的角度对他们在培训和数据收集期间的表现和经验进行定性评估。
学生们收集了详细且全面的饮食记录,并且普遍对培训和数据收集给予了积极反馈。在数据收集期间对学生进行频繁监督被证明非常有价值。虽然农村参与者愿意让学生跟踪他们,但学生在评估城市参与者的饮食时面临一些挑战。这些挑战最好通过事先对这些参与者进行单独培训来解决。
经过充分培训和监督,在使用可行且符合文化习惯的地区,大学生可能是大规模膳食调查中有用且具有成本效益的资源。有必要进一步研究这种方法在蒙古以外地区以及其他膳食评估方法和技术中的适用程度。