Shannon Lisa M, Birdwhistell Shira, Hulbig Shelia K, Jones Afton Jackson, Newell Jennifer, Payne Connie
Morehead State University, Sociology, Social Work, and Criminology, United States.
Morehead State University, Sociology, Social Work, and Criminology, United States.
Eval Program Plann. 2017 Aug;63:54-66. doi: 10.1016/j.evalprogplan.2017.03.003. Epub 2017 Mar 11.
Veterans' Treatment Courts (VTCs) are posited as a solution to offer rehabilitation for veterans involved in the criminal justice system. Despite the pervasive implementation of VTCs, there is little research focused specifically on VTC implementation and outcomes, which are based on other problem-solving court models such as drug court. The current study presents qualitative process evaluation data from key stakeholders (n=21) and veteran participants (n=4) to show accomplishments, challenges, and lessons learned during first-year implementation at two VTC sites. Quantitative performance data is also presented on veteran participants (n=19) served during the first year to show: types of services, monitoring, judicial interaction, sanctions/therapeutic responses, and rewards, as well as preliminary data on recidivism. Qualitative data, from both key stakeholders and veteran participants, suggests that offering rehabilitation via various program components, services/referrals, and accountability are critical to the success of the VTC. Data also provides valuable lessons learned for VTC implementation including communication, collaboration, information/protocols, and resources. Performance data shows that a variety of services are utilized and that frequent judicial interaction, drug testing, and sanctions are cornerstones of the VTC. Implications and future directions for research are discussed.
退伍军人治疗法庭(VTCs)被视为一种为涉及刑事司法系统的退伍军人提供康复治疗的解决方案。尽管退伍军人治疗法庭已广泛实施,但专门针对其实施情况和结果的研究却很少,这些研究是基于诸如毒品法庭等其他问题解决法庭模式。本研究展示了来自关键利益相关者(n = 21)和退伍军人参与者(n = 4)的定性过程评估数据,以呈现两个退伍军人治疗法庭站点在第一年实施期间取得的成就、面临的挑战和吸取的经验教训。还展示了第一年服务的退伍军人参与者(n = 19)的定量绩效数据,以显示:服务类型、监督、司法互动、制裁/治疗反应和奖励,以及再犯的初步数据。来自关键利益相关者和退伍军人参与者的定性数据表明,通过各种项目组成部分、服务/转介和问责制提供康复治疗对于退伍军人治疗法庭的成功至关重要。数据还为退伍军人治疗法庭的实施提供了宝贵的经验教训,包括沟通、协作、信息/协议和资源。绩效数据表明,各种服务都得到了利用,频繁的司法互动、药物检测和制裁是退伍军人治疗法庭的基石。讨论了研究的意义和未来方向。