Krouwer Jan S
1 Krouwer Consulting, Sherborn, MA, USA.
J Diabetes Sci Technol. 2017 Nov;11(6):1247-1249. doi: 10.1177/1932296817702926. Epub 2017 Apr 5.
The Diabetes Technology Society surveillance protocol provides a seal of approval for a glucose meter if a sufficient number of a candidate glucose meter's results meet ISO 15197:2013 limits. The protocol provides clear details about how to conduct this study and analyze the data but has two flaws. There is no specification about the size of glucose meter errors that are outside of ISO limits. A meter that has a result in the E zone of a glucose meter error grid could receive the DTS seal of approval. In addition, the protocol uses the ISO standard, which could be considered a "state of the art" standard instead of an error grid, which is a clinical standard. Remedies for these problems are to replace the ISO standard with an error grid and to include requirements for errors found in C or higher zones of an error grid.
糖尿病技术协会的监测方案规定,如果候选血糖仪的足够数量的检测结果符合ISO 15197:2013标准限值,那么该血糖仪就能获得认可。该方案详细说明了如何开展此项研究以及分析数据,但存在两个缺陷。对于超出ISO标准限值的血糖仪误差大小没有明确规定。处于血糖仪误差网格E区的血糖仪检测结果仍可获得糖尿病技术协会的认可。此外,该方案采用的是ISO标准,这可被视为一种“先进水平”标准,而非作为临床标准的误差网格。针对这些问题的解决办法是用误差网格取代ISO标准,并纳入对误差网格C区或更高区域中发现的误差的要求。