Kowalczuk Krystyna, Krajewska-Kułak Elżbieta
Department of Integrated Medical Care, Medical University of Bialystok, Poland.
Ann Agric Environ Med. 2017 Mar 31;24(1):113-116. doi: 10.5604/12321966.1228395.
Patient aggression affects healthcare quality and, in extreme situations, may even lead to medical malpractice. Little is known, however, about the specific distribution of health care professionals' exposure to patient aggression in various countries.
The aim of this study was to assess the exposure of various professional groups of healthcare personnel to patient aggression, and to identify potential determinants (medical profession, age, gender, professional experience and employment at outpatient/inpatient healthcare units) of this exposure.
The study was performed between January 2008 - December 2009 in northeastern Poland, and included 1,624 healthcare workers (493 nurses, 504 midwives, 501 physicians and 126 medical rescue workers). Exposure to eight forms of patient aggression was assessed using the MDM Mobbing Questionnaire.
Using a raised voice was the most frequently observed form of aggression in all groups, whereas the least frequent form of aggression encountered was the use of direct physical violence. In inpatient healthcare units, the intensity of patient aggression was encountered most by nurses and medical rescue workers, followed by physicians and midwives. In outpatient healthcare units, medical rescue workers experienced significantly higher levels of aggression when compared to other professional groups. Significant differences in mean aggression intensity experienced in inpatient and outpatient healthcare units were observed only in nurses and physicians. Furthermore, no significant effects of gender were observed on the intensity of patient aggression.
Nurses are most exposed to different forms of patient aggression, with verbal attacks being most prevalent. Nurses employed at inpatient healthcare units experienced aggression more frequently than those working in outpatient healthcare units.
患者攻击行为会影响医疗质量,在极端情况下甚至可能导致医疗事故。然而,对于不同国家医疗保健专业人员遭受患者攻击行为的具体分布情况,我们知之甚少。
本研究旨在评估各类医疗保健人员遭受患者攻击行为的情况,并确定这种暴露的潜在决定因素(医学专业、年龄、性别、专业经验以及在门诊/住院医疗单位的工作情况)。
该研究于2008年1月至2009年12月在波兰东北部进行,纳入了1624名医护人员(493名护士、504名助产士、501名医生和126名医疗救援人员)。使用MDM职场暴力问卷评估遭受八种形式患者攻击行为的情况。
在所有组中,提高嗓门是最常观察到的攻击形式,而遇到最少的攻击形式是直接身体暴力。在住院医疗单位,护士和医疗救援人员遭遇患者攻击行为的强度最高,其次是医生和助产士。在门诊医疗单位,与其他专业组相比,医疗救援人员遭受的攻击水平显著更高。仅在护士和医生中观察到住院和门诊医疗单位平均攻击强度的显著差异。此外,未观察到性别对患者攻击行为强度有显著影响。
护士最容易遭受不同形式的患者攻击行为,言语攻击最为普遍。在住院医疗单位工作的护士比在门诊医疗单位工作的护士更频繁地遭遇攻击行为。