Lee Jiyeon
Department of Speech, Language, and Hearing Sciences, Purdue University, West Lafayette, IN.
J Speech Lang Hear Res. 2017 Apr 14;60(4):924-936. doi: 10.1044/2016_JSLHR-L-15-0350.
Growing evidence suggests that sentence formulation is affected in Parkinson's disease (PD); however, how speakers with PD coordinate sentence planning and speaking remains unclear. Within 2 competing models of sentence production, this study examined whether speakers with PD show advanced buffering of words to minimize disfluencies and increased demands during speech or whether they plan one word at a time, compromising accuracy and fluency of speech.
Participants described 3 computer-displayed pictures using the sentence "the A and the B are above the C." Name agreement (codability) was varied to be high (clock) or low (sofa/couch) for each object position (A, B, C), affecting difficulty of lexical selection. Participants' gaze durations to each object were recorded.
Speakers with PD showed incremental word-by-word planning, retrieving only the first lexical item (A) before speech onset, similar to controls. However, they produced greater word-finding errors and disfluencies compared to controls for the low-codable pictures, but not for high-codable pictures.
These findings suggest that by following word-by-word incremental production, speakers with PD compromise fluency and accuracy of speech to a greater extent than healthy older speakers and that PD is associated with impaired inhibitory control during lexical selection.
越来越多的证据表明帕金森病(PD)患者的句子构建受到影响;然而,PD患者在句子规划和言语表达过程中是如何进行协调的仍不清楚。在两种相互竞争的句子生成模型中,本研究考察了PD患者是否会对单词进行提前缓冲以尽量减少言语不流畅性并降低言语过程中的需求,或者他们是否一次只计划一个单词,从而影响言语的准确性和流畅性。
参与者用 “A和B在C的上方” 这句话描述三张电脑显示屏上的图片。对于每个物体位置(A、B、C),名称一致性(可编码性)分为高(时钟)或低(沙发)两种情况,这会影响词汇选择的难度。记录参与者对每个物体的注视时间。
与对照组一样,PD患者表现出逐词递增式的规划,在言语开始前只提取第一个词汇项(A)。然而,与对照组相比,对于低可编码图片,他们出现了更多的找词错误和言语不流畅性,但对于高可编码图片则没有。
这些发现表明,通过采用逐词递增式生成方式,PD患者在言语流畅性和准确性方面比健康的老年说话者受到更大的影响,并且PD与词汇选择过程中抑制控制受损有关。