Croley Julie Amthor, Reese Vail, Wagner Richard F
Department of Dermatology, The University of Texas Medical Branch, Galveston.
Union Square Dermatology, San Francisco, California.
JAMA Dermatol. 2017 Jun 1;153(6):559-564. doi: 10.1001/jamadermatol.2016.5979.
Dichotomous dermatologic depictions of heroes and villains in movies have been used since the silent film age.
To evaluate the hero-villain skin dichotomy in film by (1) identifying dermatologic findings of the all-time top 10 American film villains, (2) comparing these dermatologic findings to the all-time top 10 American film heroes quantitatively and qualitatively, and (3) analyzing dermatologic portrayals of film villains in depth.
DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS: In this cross-sectional study, dermatologic findings for film heroes and villains in mainstream media were identified and compared quantitatively using a χ2 test with α < .05, as well as qualitatively. The all-time top 10 American film villains and heroes were obtained from the American Film Institute 100 Greatest Heroes and Villains List.
Primary outcomes include identification and frequencies of dermatologic findings of the top 10 film villains and of the top 10 film heroes.
Six (60%) of the all-time top 10 American film villains have dermatologic findings, including cosmetically significant alopecia (30%), periorbital hyperpigmentation (30%), deep rhytides on the face (20%), multiple facial scars (20%), verruca vulgaris on the face (20%), and rhinophyma (10%). The top 10 villains have a higher incidence of significant dermatologic findings than the top 10 heroes (60% vs 0%; P = .03).
Dermatologic findings of the all-time top 10 American villains are used in film to highlight the dichotomy of good and evil, which may foster a tendency toward prejudice in our society directed at those with skin disease.
自无声电影时代以来,电影中就一直存在对英雄和反派的二元化皮肤病学描绘。
通过(1)识别有史以来排名前十的美国电影反派的皮肤病学表现,(2)将这些皮肤病学表现与有史以来排名前十的美国电影英雄进行定量和定性比较,以及(3)深入分析电影反派的皮肤病学刻画,来评估电影中的英雄 - 反派皮肤二分法。
设计、背景和参与者:在这项横断面研究中,使用α <.05的χ²检验对主流媒体中电影英雄和反派的皮肤病学表现进行识别并定量比较,同时进行定性比较。有史以来排名前十的美国电影反派和英雄来自美国电影学会的100位最伟大英雄和反派名单。
主要结局包括排名前十的电影反派和排名前十的电影英雄的皮肤病学表现的识别和频率。
有史以来排名前十的美国电影反派中有六个(60%)有皮肤病学表现,包括具有美容意义的脱发(30%)、眶周色素沉着(30%)、面部深层皱纹(20%)、多处面部疤痕(20%)、面部寻常疣(20%)和酒渣鼻(10%)。排名前十的反派有明显皮肤病学表现的发生率高于排名前十的英雄(60%对0%;P = 0.03)。
有史以来排名前十的美国反派的皮肤病学表现在电影中被用来突出善恶二分法,这可能会助长我们社会中针对皮肤病患者的偏见倾向。