Qirbi Naseeb, Ismail Sharif A
Department of Community Medicine, Faculty of Medicine and Health Science, Sana'a University, Sana'a, Yemen.
Department of Primary Care and Public Health, Imperial College London, Reynolds Building, St. Dunstan's Road, London, UK.
Health Policy Plan. 2017 Jul 1;32(6):911-922. doi: 10.1093/heapol/czx031.
Although the literature on effects of armed conflict on population health is extensive, detailed assessments of effects on public health 'systems' are few. This article aims to help address this deficit through the medium of a case study on Yemen, describing health system and health outcome performance prior to the internationalisation of the conflict there in March 2015, before assessing the impact of war on health system functionality since that time.
Review of peer- and non-peer reviewed literature from 2005 to 2016 from academic sources, multilateral organizations, donors and governmental and non-governmental organizations, augmented by secondary data analysis.
Despite significant health system weaknesses and structural vulnerabilities pre-conflict, there were important improvements in selected health outcome measures in Yemen up to early 2015 (life expectancy, and infant and maternal mortality, e.g.), partly driven by a fragile health sector that was heavily reliant on out-of-pocket expenditure, and hampered by weak service penetration especially in rural areas. High intensity conflict has resulted in rising mortality and injury rates since March 2015, the first decline in life expectancy and increase in child and maternal mortality in Yemen for some years, and worsening levels of malnutrition. Service delivery has become increasingly challenging in the context of a funding crisis, destruction of health facilities, widespread shortages of essential medicines and equipment across the country, and governance fragmentation.
Conflict in Yemen has resulted in humanitarian disaster on a wide scale in a short period of time, and crippled an already weak health system. Important areas of uncertainty remain, however, including the scale of health worker flight, and the extent to which alternative providers have stepped in to fill widening service gaps as the conflict has unfolded. Planning for longer-term health system reconstruction should begin as soon as possible.
尽管关于武装冲突对人口健康影响的文献颇为丰富,但对公共卫生“系统”影响的详细评估却为数不多。本文旨在通过也门的案例研究来填补这一空白,先描述2015年3月冲突国际化之前也门的卫生系统及健康成果表现,再评估自那时起战争对卫生系统功能的影响。
对2005年至2016年来自学术机构、多边组织、捐助方以及政府和非政府组织的同行评审和非同行评审文献进行综述,并辅以二次数据分析。
尽管冲突前也门的卫生系统存在重大弱点和结构性漏洞,但到2015年初,也门在某些健康成果指标方面取得了重要进展(如预期寿命、婴儿及孕产妇死亡率等),部分原因是脆弱的卫生部门严重依赖自付费用,且服务覆盖不足,尤其是在农村地区。自2015年3月以来,高强度冲突导致死亡率和受伤率上升,也门的预期寿命首次下降,儿童及孕产妇死亡率在数年后首次上升,营养不良状况也日益恶化。在资金危机、卫生设施遭到破坏、全国基本药品和设备普遍短缺以及治理碎片化的背景下,服务提供变得越来越具有挑战性。
也门的冲突在短时间内造成了大规模的人道主义灾难,并使本就薄弱的卫生系统陷入瘫痪。然而,仍存在一些重要的不确定领域,包括卫生工作者外流的规模,以及随着冲突的展开,替代提供者在填补不断扩大的服务缺口方面所发挥作用的程度。应尽快开始规划长期的卫生系统重建工作。