Wurz Amanda, Brunet Jennifer
School of Human Kinetics, Faculty of Health Sciences, University of Ottawa, Ottawa, ON, Canada.
JMIR Cancer. 2016 May 24;2(1):e6. doi: 10.2196/cancer.5431.
There are numerous published controlled trials assessing the safety and the benefits of physical activity (PA) for child and adult cancer survivors. However, trials exclusively comprised of adolescent cancer survivors aged 13-19 years, who may experience different health and quality of life (QOL) effects as a function of their developmental status, are lacking. Rather, some trials have included both adolescent and child cancer survivors together.
The aim of this systematic review was to synthesize the findings from randomized controlled trails (RCTs) and controlled clinical trials (CCTs) investigating the effects of PA on health and QOL outcomes in samples comprised of >50% adolescent cancer survivors to summarize the current state of evidence, identify knowledge gaps, and highlight areas in need of additional research within this population.
Using a search strategy developed for this review, 10 electronic databases were searched for RCTs and CCTs that reported on the effects of PA on at least 1 health and/or QOL outcome in samples comprised of >50% adolescent cancer survivors.
From the 2249 articles identified, 2 CCTs met the predetermined eligibility criteria and were included in this review. Combined, 28 adolescents (of 41 participants) who were receiving active treatment participated in the 2 studies reviewed. A total of 4 health and QOL outcomes (ie, bone mass, fatigue, grip strength, QOL) were assessed pre- and post-PA intervention.
On the basis of the 2 studies reviewed, PA appears to be safe and feasible. PA also shows promise to mitigate reductions in bone mass and might be a viable strategy to improve fatigue, grip strength, and QOL. High-quality controlled trials with larger samples exclusively comprised of adolescent cancer survivors that assess a wide range of outcomes are needed to determine the effects of PA on health and QOL outcomes in this population.
已有众多发表的对照试验评估了体育活动(PA)对儿童和成人癌症幸存者的安全性和益处。然而,专门针对13至19岁青少年癌症幸存者的试验却很缺乏,这些青少年可能因其发育状况而经历不同的健康和生活质量(QOL)影响。相反,一些试验同时纳入了青少年和儿童癌症幸存者。
本系统评价的目的是综合随机对照试验(RCT)和对照临床试验(CCT)的结果,这些试验调查了PA对样本中超过50%为青少年癌症幸存者的健康和QOL结局的影响,以总结当前的证据状态,识别知识空白,并突出该人群中需要进一步研究的领域。
使用为本评价制定的检索策略,在10个电子数据库中检索RCT和CCT,这些试验报告了PA对样本中超过50%为青少年癌症幸存者的至少1项健康和/或QOL结局的影响。
从识别出的2249篇文章中,有2项CCT符合预定的纳入标准并被纳入本评价。两项研究中共有41名参与者,其中28名正在接受积极治疗的青少年参与了综述的这两项研究。在PA干预前后共评估了4项健康和QOL结局(即骨量、疲劳、握力、QOL)。
基于所综述的两项研究,PA似乎是安全可行的。PA还有望减轻骨量的减少,可能是改善疲劳、握力和QOL的可行策略。需要进行高质量的对照试验,样本专门由青少年癌症幸存者组成且规模更大,评估广泛的结局,以确定PA对该人群健康和QOL结局的影响。