Lambert Lukas, Ourednicek Petr, Meckova Zuzana, Gavelli Giampaolo, Straub Jan, Spicka Ivan
Department of Radiology, First Faculty of Medicine, Charles University and General University Hospital in Prague, 128 08 Prague, Czech Republic.
Department of Imaging Methods, St. Anne's University Hospital in Brno, 656 91 Brno, Czech Republic.
Oncol Lett. 2017 Apr;13(4):2490-2494. doi: 10.3892/ol.2017.5723. Epub 2017 Feb 13.
The primary objective of the present prospective study was to compare the diagnostic performance of conventional radiography (CR) and whole-body low-dose computed tomography (WBLDCT) with a comparable radiation dose reconstructed using hybrid iterative reconstruction technique, in terms of the detection of bone lesions, skeletal fractures, vertebral compressions and extraskeletal findings. The secondary objective was to evaluate lesion attenuation in relation to its size. A total of 74 patients underwent same-day skeletal survey by CR and WBLDCT. In CR and WBLDCT, two readers assessed the number of osteolytic lesions at each region and stage according to the International Myeloma Working Group (IMWG) criteria. A single reader additionally assessed extraskeletal findings and their significance, the number of vertebral compressions and bone fractures. The radiation exposure was 2.7±0.9 mSv for WBLDCT and 2.5±0.9 mSv for CR (P=0.054). CR detected bone involvement in 127 out of 486 regions (26%; P<0.0001), confirmed by WBLDCT. CR underestimated the disease stage in 16% and overestimated it in 8% of the patients (P=0.0077). WBLDCT detected more rib fractures compared with CR (188 vs. 47; P<0.0001), vertebral compressions (93 vs. 67; P=0.010) and extraskeletal findings (194 vs. 52; P<0.0001). There was no correlation observed between lesion size (≥5 mm) and its attenuation (r=-0.006; P=0.93). The inter-observer agreement for the presence of osteolytic lesions was κ=0.76 for WBLDCT, and κ=0.55 for CR. The present study concluded that WBLDCT with hybrid iterative reconstruction technique demonstrates superiority to CR with an identical radiation dose in the detection of bone lesions, skeletal fractures, vertebral compressions and extraskeletal findings, which results in up- or downstaging in 24% patients according to the IMWG criteria. The attenuation of osteolytic lesions can be measured with the avoidance of the partial volume effect.
本前瞻性研究的主要目的是比较传统放射成像(CR)与使用混合迭代重建技术重建的具有可比辐射剂量的全身低剂量计算机断层扫描(WBLDCT)在检测骨病变、骨骼骨折、椎体压缩和骨骼外表现方面的诊断性能。次要目的是评估病变衰减与其大小的关系。共有74例患者同日接受了CR和WBLDCT的骨骼检查。在CR和WBLDCT检查中,两名阅片者根据国际骨髓瘤工作组(IMWG)标准评估每个区域和阶段的溶骨性病变数量。一名阅片者还额外评估了骨骼外表现及其意义、椎体压缩和骨折的数量。WBLDCT的辐射暴露为2.7±0.9 mSv,CR为2.5±0.9 mSv(P=0.054)。CR在486个区域中的127个区域检测到骨受累(26%;P<0.0001),WBLDCT证实了这一结果。CR在16%的患者中低估了疾病分期,在8%的患者中高估了疾病分期(P=0.0077)。与CR相比,WBLDCT检测到更多的肋骨骨折(188例对47例;P<0.0001))、椎体压缩(93例对67例;P=0.010)和骨骼外表现(194例对52例;P<0.0001)。未观察到病变大小(≥5 mm)与其衰减之间的相关性(r=-0.006;P=0.93)。对于溶骨性病变的存在,WBLDCT的观察者间一致性κ=0.76,CR为κ=0.55。本研究得出结论,采用混合迭代重建技术的WBLDCT在检测骨病变、骨骼骨折、椎体压缩和骨骼外表现方面,在相同辐射剂量下优于CR,根据IMWG标准,这导致24%的患者分期上调或下调。可以测量溶骨性病变的衰减,同时避免部分容积效应。