Zhu Qianqian, Li Na, Li Fang, Zhou Zhihua, Sang Jiao, Zeng Xiaoyan, Han Qunying, Lv Yi, Zhao Wenxuan, Liu Zhengwen
Department of Infectious Diseases.
Department of Laboratory Medicine.
Ther Clin Risk Manag. 2017 Apr 18;13:545-553. doi: 10.2147/TCRM.S131290. eCollection 2017.
The treatment of hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) involves multidisciplinary clinical divisions and patients may be admitted to clinical divisions of different disciplinary nature. Few studies have assessed the potential effect of hospital admissions into different divisions on patient treatment options and survival. This study aimed to analyze this potential effect.
We analyzed data of HCC patients between 2002 and 2011 in a large hospital of northwest China and compared the treatment options and patient outcomes following initial admission into two major clinical disciplinary divisions: internal medicine and surgical. Barcelona Clinic Liver Cancer criteria were used for staging.
The study included 2,045 patients. Analysis showed that more patients initially admitted to surgical divisions received curative treatments (resection, transplantation, and local ablation) than those admitted to internal medicine divisions; while more patients initially hospitalized to internal medicine divisions chose supportive care than those admitted to surgical divisions. Stages 0, A, and B patients initially admitted to surgical divisions had higher survival rates compared with those initially admitted to internal medicine divisions (=0.036, 0.057 and 0.001, respectively). Survival rates of patients who were in stages C and D showed no differences. The survival differences between patients initially admitted to internal medicine and surgical divisions vanished after adjusting for treatment distribution.
This study showed that the initial hospitalization divisions may affect the outcome of HCC patients because of different treatment options, suggesting that enforcing multidisciplinary collaboration to optimize the treatment of HCC patients at various stages may improve patient survival.
肝细胞癌(HCC)的治疗涉及多学科临床科室,患者可能入住不同学科性质的临床科室。很少有研究评估入住不同科室对患者治疗选择和生存的潜在影响。本研究旨在分析这种潜在影响。
我们分析了中国西北部一家大型医院2002年至2011年期间HCC患者的数据,并比较了初次入住两个主要临床学科科室(内科和外科)后的治疗选择和患者预后。采用巴塞罗那临床肝癌标准进行分期。
该研究纳入了2045例患者。分析表明,与入住内科科室的患者相比,初次入住外科科室的患者接受根治性治疗(切除、移植和局部消融)的更多;而初次入住内科科室的患者选择支持治疗的比入住外科科室的更多。初次入住外科科室的0期、A期和B期患者的生存率高于初次入住内科科室的患者(分别为P=0.036、0.057和0.001)。C期和D期患者的生存率没有差异。在调整治疗分布后,初次入住内科和外科科室患者之间的生存差异消失。
本研究表明,由于治疗选择不同,初次住院科室可能影响HCC患者的预后,这表明加强多学科协作以优化各期HCC患者的治疗可能提高患者生存率。