Wong William C W, Jiang Sunfang, Ong Jason J, Peng Minghui, Wan Eric, Zhu Shanzhu, Lam Cindy L K, Kidd Michael R, Roland Martin
Department of Family Medicine and Primary Care, University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong, China.
General Practice Department, Fudan University, Shanghai, China
Ann Fam Med. 2017 May;15(3):237-245. doi: 10.1370/afm.2034.
China introduced a national policy of developing primary care in 2009, establishing 8,669 community health centers (CHCs) by 2014 that employed more than 300,000 staff. These facilities have been underused, however, because of public mistrust of physicians and overreliance on specialist care.
We selected a stratified random sample of CHCs throughout China based on geographic distribution and urban-suburban ratios between September and December 2015. Two questionnaires, 1 for lead clinicians and 1 for primary care practitioners (PCPs), asked about the demographics of the clinic and its clinical and educational activities. Responses were obtained from 158 lead clinicians in CHCs and 3,580 PCPs (response rates of 84% and 86%, respectively).
CHCs employed a median of 8 physicians and 13 nurses, but only one-half of physicians were registered as PCPs, and few nurses had training specifically for primary care. Although virtually all clinics were equipped with stethoscopes (98%) and sphygmomanometers (97%), only 43% had ophthalmoscopes and 64% had facilities for gynecologic examination. Clinical care was selectively skewed toward certain chronic diseases. Physicians saw a median of 12.5 patients per day. Multivariate analysis showed that more patients were seen daily by physicians in CHCs organized by private hospitals and those having pharmacists and nurses.
Our survey confirms China's success in establishing a large, mostly young primary care workforce and providing ongoing professional training. Facilities are basic, however, with few clinics providing the comprehensive primary care required for a wide range of common physical and mental conditions. Use of CHCs by patients remains low.
中国于2009年出台了发展基层医疗的国家政策,到2014年建立了8669个社区卫生中心(CHC),雇佣了超过30万名工作人员。然而,由于公众对医生的不信任以及对专科医疗的过度依赖,这些机构未得到充分利用。
我们根据地理分布和城乡比例,于2015年9月至12月在中国各地选取了CHC的分层随机样本。向首席临床医生和基层医疗从业者(PCP)分别发放了两份问卷,询问诊所的人口统计学信息及其临床和教育活动。从CHC的158名首席临床医生和3580名PCP处获得了回复(回复率分别为84%和86%)。
CHC的医生中位数为8名,护士中位数为13名,但只有一半的医生注册为PCP,很少有护士接受过专门的基层医疗培训。尽管几乎所有诊所都配备了听诊器(98%)和血压计(97%),但只有43%有检眼镜,64%有妇科检查设施。临床护理选择性地偏向某些慢性病。医生每天的门诊患者中位数为12.5人。多变量分析显示,由私立医院组织的CHC以及有药剂师和护士的CHC中,医生每天看的患者更多。
我们的调查证实了中国在建立一支庞大的、大多年轻的基层医疗队伍并提供持续专业培训方面取得的成功。然而,设施较为基础,很少有诊所能够提供针对广泛常见身心疾病所需的全面基层医疗服务。患者对CHC的利用率仍然很低。