Malone Susan Kohl, Patterson Freda, Lozano Alicia, Hanlon Alexandra
a Center for Sleep and Circadian Neurobiology, Perelman School of Medicine , University of Pennsylvania , Philadelphia PA , USA.
b Rory Meyers College of Nursing , New York University , New York , NY , USA.
Chronobiol Int. 2017;34(6):740-752. doi: 10.1080/07420528.2017.1317639. Epub 2017 May 10.
Biological evidence suggests that ethno-racial differences in morning-evening type are possible, whereby Blacks may be more likely to be morning type compared to Whites. However, population-level evidence of ethno-racial difference in morning-evening type is limited. In an earlier study, we reported that morning type was more prevalent in Blacks compared to Whites in the United Kingdom (UK) Biobank cohort (N = 439 933). This study aimed to determine if these ethno-racial differences persisted after accounting for an even broader range of social, environmental and individual characteristics and employing an analytic approach that simulates randomization in observational data, propensity score modeling. Data from UK Biobank participants whose self-identified race/ethnicity was Black/Black British or White; who did not report daytime napping, shift work or night shift work; who provided full mental health information; and who were identified using propensity score matching were used (N = 2044). Each sample was strongly matched across all social, environmental and individual characteristics as indicated by absolute standardized mean differences <0.09 for all variables. The prevalence of reporting nocturnal short, adequate and long sleep as well as morning, intermediate and evening type among Blacks (n = 1022) was compared with a matched sample of Whites (n = 1022) using multinomial logistic regression models. Blacks had a 62% greater odds of being morning type [odds ratio (OR) = 1.620, 95% confidence interval (CI): 1.336-1.964, p < .0001] and a more than threefold greater odds of reporting nocturnal short sleep (OR = 3.453, 95% CI: 2.846-4.190, p < .0001) than Whites. These data indicate that the greater prevalence of morning type and short nocturnal sleep in Blacks compared to Whites is not fully explained by a wide range of social and environmental factors. If sleep is an upstream determinant of health, these data suggest that ethno-racially targeted public health sleep intervention strategies are needed.
生物学证据表明,晨型-夜型在不同种族间可能存在差异,黑人可能比白人更倾向于成为晨型人。然而,关于晨型-夜型种族差异的人群层面证据有限。在一项早期研究中,我们报告称,在英国生物银行队列(N = 439933)中,黑人的晨型比白人更为普遍。本研究旨在确定,在考虑更广泛的社会、环境和个体特征,并采用一种在观察性数据中模拟随机化的分析方法(倾向得分建模)后,这些种族差异是否仍然存在。使用了来自英国生物银行参与者的数据,这些参与者自我认定的种族/族裔为黑人/英国黑人或白人;未报告白天午睡、轮班工作或夜班工作;提供了完整的心理健康信息;并且通过倾向得分匹配进行识别(N = 2044)。如所有变量的绝对标准化均值差异<0.09所示,每个样本在所有社会、环境和个体特征上都进行了严格匹配。使用多项逻辑回归模型,将黑人(n = 1022)中报告夜间短睡眠、充足睡眠和长睡眠以及晨型、中间型和夜型的患病率与匹配的白人样本(n = 1022)进行比较。与白人相比,黑人成为晨型人的几率高62%[优势比(OR)= 1.620,95%置信区间(CI):1.336 - 1.964,p <.0001],报告夜间短睡眠的几率高出三倍多(OR = 3.453,95% CI:2.846 - 4.190,p <.0001)。这些数据表明,黑人中晨型和夜间短睡眠的患病率高于白人,这并不能完全由广泛的社会和环境因素来解释。如果睡眠是健康的上游决定因素,这些数据表明需要针对不同种族的公共卫生睡眠干预策略。