Arnaud Mickael, Bégaud Bernard, Thurin Nicolas, Moore Nicholas, Pariente Antoine, Salvo Francesco
a University of Bordeaux , Bordeaux , France.
b Bordeaux Population Health Research Centre, Pharmacoepidemiology team , INSERM UMR1219 , Bordeaux , France.
Expert Opin Drug Saf. 2017 Jun;16(6):721-732. doi: 10.1080/14740338.2017.1325463. Epub 2017 May 15.
With increasing availability, the use of healthcare databases as complementary data source for drug safety signal detection has been explored to circumvent the limitations inherent in spontaneous reporting. Areas covered: To review the methods proposed for safety signal detection in healthcare databases and their performance. Expert opinion: Fifteen different data mining methods were identified. They are based on disproportionality analysis, traditional pharmacoepidemiological designs (e.g. self-controlled designs), sequence symmetry analysis (SSA), sequential statistical testing, temporal association rules, supervised machine learning (SML), and the tree-based scan statistic. When considering the performance of these methods, the self-controlled designs, the SSA, and the SML seemed the most interesting approaches. In the perspective of routine signal detection from healthcare databases, pragmatic aspects such as the need for stakeholders to understand the method in order to be confident in the results must be considered. From this point of view, the SSA could appear as the most suitable method for signal detection in healthcare databases owing to its simple principle and its ability to provide a risk estimate. However, further developments, such as automated prioritization, are needed to help stakeholders handle the multiplicity of signals.
随着医疗保健数据库可用性的提高,人们已经探索将其作为药物安全信号检测的补充数据源,以规避自发报告中固有的局限性。涵盖领域:回顾医疗保健数据库中提出的安全信号检测方法及其性能。专家意见:确定了15种不同的数据挖掘方法。它们基于不成比例分析、传统药物流行病学设计(如自我对照设计)、序列对称性分析(SSA)、序贯统计检验、时间关联规则、监督机器学习(SML)以及基于树的扫描统计量。在考虑这些方法的性能时,自我对照设计、SSA和SML似乎是最有吸引力的方法。从医疗保健数据库进行常规信号检测的角度来看,必须考虑一些实际问题,例如利益相关者需要理解该方法以便对结果有信心。从这一点来看,由于其原理简单且能够提供风险估计,SSA可能是医疗保健数据库中信号检测最合适的方法。然而,还需要进一步发展,如自动排序,以帮助利益相关者处理众多的信号。