Poirier Therese I, Pailden Junvie, Jhala Ray, Ronald Katie, Wilhelm Miranda, Fan Jingyang
Southern Illinois University Edwardsville, Edwardsville, Illinois.
Am J Pharm Educ. 2017 Apr;81(3):54. doi: 10.5688/ajpe81354.
To conduct a prospective evaluation for effectiveness of an error disclosure assessment tool and video recordings to enhance student learning and metacognitive skills while assessing the IPEC competencies. The instruments for assessing performance (planning, communication, process, and team dynamics) in interprofessional error disclosure were developed. Student self-assessment of performance before and after viewing the recordings of their encounters were obtained. Faculty used a similar instrument to conduct real-time assessments. An instrument to assess achievement of the Interprofessional Education Collaborative (IPEC) core competencies was developed. Qualitative data was reviewed to determine student and faculty perceptions of the simulation. The interprofessional simulation training involved a total of 233 students (50 dental, 109 nursing and 74 pharmacy). Use of video recordings made a significant difference in student self-assessment for communication and process categories of error disclosure. No differences in student self-assessments were noted among the different professions. There were differences among the family member affects for planning and communication for both pre-video and post-video data. There were significant differences between student self-assessment and faculty assessment for all paired comparisons, except communication in student post-video self-assessment. Students' perceptions of achievement of the IPEC core competencies were positive. The use of assessment instruments and video recordings may have enhanced students' metacognitive skills for assessing performance in interprofessional error disclosure. The simulation training was effective in enhancing perceptions on achievement of IPEC core competencies. This enhanced assessment process appeared to enhance learning about the skills needed for interprofessional error disclosure.
为了对错误披露评估工具和视频记录的有效性进行前瞻性评估,以提高学生的学习和元认知技能,同时评估IPEC能力。开发了用于评估跨专业错误披露中表现(规划、沟通、过程和团队动态)的工具。获取了学生在观看其遭遇记录前后的自我表现评估。教师使用类似工具进行实时评估。开发了一种用于评估跨专业教育协作(IPEC)核心能力达成情况的工具。对定性数据进行审查,以确定学生和教师对模拟的看法。跨专业模拟培训总共涉及233名学生(50名牙科、109名护理和74名药学专业)。视频记录的使用在学生对错误披露的沟通和过程类别自我评估中产生了显著差异。不同专业的学生自我评估未发现差异。在视频前和视频后数据中,家庭成员对规划和沟通的影响存在差异。除了学生视频后自我评估中的沟通外,所有配对比较中,学生自我评估和教师评估之间都存在显著差异。学生对IPEC核心能力达成情况的看法是积极的。评估工具和视频记录的使用可能增强了学生在评估跨专业错误披露表现方面的元认知技能。模拟培训有效地增强了对IPEC核心能力达成情况的认知。这种强化的评估过程似乎增强了对跨专业错误披露所需技能的学习。