Munakomi S, Kumar B M
Department of Neurosurgery, College of Medical Sciences, International Society for Medical Education, Chitwan, Nepal.
Ann Med Health Sci Res. 2016 Sep-Oct;6(5):296-300. doi: 10.4103/amhsr.amhsr_392_15.
The dilemma in managing patients with low back ache lies in differentiating radiculopathy from lumbar canal stenosis. This has a huge bearing in patients being planned for surgical intervention as underperforming leads to failed back syndrome whereas over-doing leads to instability. There still remains a loophole in clinically diagnosing lumbar canal stenosis.
We opt to utilize a simple bedside clinical examination in routinely assessing patients presenting with low back ache in ruling out underlying canal stenosis.
We performed a prospective study on 120 consecutive patients presenting with low back ache in the spine clinic. Each of them was neurologically examined and thoroughly assessed for wasting of extensor digitorum brevis (EDB) muscles. These were then correlated with the radio-imaging and the intraoperative findings.
Lumbar canal stenosis was mostly observed in the age group of 50-60 years. Diagnosis for L3/4 canal stenosis was made in 44/120 (36.6%), L5-S1 in 52/120 (43.3%), and L3/L4/L5 level in 48/120 (40%) of patients. EDB wasting was seen unilaterally in 72/120 (60%) and bilaterally in 36/120 (30%) of the study group.
This study appraises the clinical implication of observing for the wasting of EDB muscle so as to aid in the diagnosis of lumbar canal stenosis. This simple bedside clinical pearl can help us in predicting the need of further imaging studies and also in taking right therapeutic decision.
管理下背痛患者的困境在于区分神经根病和腰椎管狭窄。这对于计划进行手术干预的患者至关重要,因为治疗不足会导致背部综合征失败,而过度治疗会导致不稳定。在临床诊断腰椎管狭窄方面仍然存在漏洞。
我们选择采用一种简单的床边临床检查方法,对出现下背痛的患者进行常规评估,以排除潜在的椎管狭窄。
我们对脊柱门诊连续120例出现下背痛的患者进行了前瞻性研究。对他们每个人进行神经学检查,并对拇短伸肌(EDB)肌肉萎缩进行全面评估。然后将这些结果与影像学和术中发现进行关联。
腰椎管狭窄多见于50 - 60岁年龄组。44/120(36.6%)的患者被诊断为L3/4椎管狭窄,52/120(43.3%)为L5 - S1,48/120(40%)为L3/L4/L5水平。在研究组中,72/120(60%)的患者单侧出现EDB肌肉萎缩,36/120(30%)双侧出现。
本研究评估了观察EDB肌肉萎缩的临床意义,以辅助腰椎管狭窄的诊断。这种简单的床边临床要点可以帮助我们预测进一步影像学检查的必要性,并做出正确的治疗决策。