Yu Weiyu, Wardrop Nicola A, Bain Robert, Wright Jim A
Geography and Environment, University of Southampton, Southampton, Hampshire, SO17 1BJ, United Kingdom.
Geography and Environment, University of Southampton, Southampton, Hampshire, SO17 1BJ, United Kingdom.
Int J Hyg Environ Health. 2017 Jul;220(5):888-899. doi: 10.1016/j.ijheh.2017.04.006. Epub 2017 May 4.
Sustainable Development Goal (SDG) 6 has expanded the Millennium Development Goals' focus from improved drinking-water to safely managed water services. This expanded focus to include issues such as water quality requires richer monitoring data and potentially integration of datasets from different sources. Relevant data sets include water point mapping (WPM), the survey of boreholes, wells and other water points, census and household survey data. This study examined inconsistencies between population census and WPM datasets for Cambodia, Liberia and Tanzania, and identified potential barriers to integrating the two datasets to meet monitoring needs. Literatures on numbers of people served per water point were used to convert WPM data to population served by water source type per area and compared with census reports. For Cambodia and Tanzania, discrepancies with census data suggested incomplete WPM coverage. In Liberia, where the data sets were consistent, WPM-derived data on functionality, quantity and quality of drinking water were further combined with census area statistics to generate an enhanced drinking-water access measure for protected wells and springs. The process revealed barriers to integrating census and WPM data, including exclusion of water points not used for drinking by households, matching of census and WPM source types; temporal mismatches between data sources; data quality issues such as missing or implausible data values, and underlying assumptions about population served by different water point technologies. However, integration of these two data sets could be used to identify and rectify gaps in WPM coverage. If WPM databases become more complete and the above barriers are addressed, it could also be used to develop more realistic measures of household drinking-water access for monitoring.
可持续发展目标6(SDG 6)已将千年发展目标的重点从改善饮用水扩大到安全管理的供水服务。这种扩大后的重点,包括水质等问题,需要更丰富的监测数据,并可能整合来自不同来源的数据集。相关数据集包括取水点地图绘制(WPM)、钻孔、水井及其他取水点的调查、人口普查和住户调查数据。本研究调查了柬埔寨、利比里亚和坦桑尼亚人口普查与取水点地图绘制数据集之间的不一致之处,并确定了整合这两个数据集以满足监测需求的潜在障碍。利用关于每个取水点服务人数的文献,将取水点地图绘制数据转换为按地区划分的各类水源服务的人口数,并与人口普查报告进行比较。对于柬埔寨和坦桑尼亚,与人口普查数据的差异表明取水点地图绘制覆盖不完整。在数据集一致的利比里亚,取水点地图绘制得出的关于饮用水功能、数量和质量的数据进一步与人口普查地区统计数据相结合,以生成受保护水井和泉水的强化饮用水获取量度。该过程揭示了整合人口普查和取水点地图绘制数据的障碍,包括排除家庭未用于饮用的取水点、人口普查与取水点地图绘制数据源类型的匹配;数据源之间的时间不匹配;数据质量问题,如数据值缺失或不合理,以及关于不同取水点技术服务人口的潜在假设。然而,整合这两个数据集可用于识别和纠正取水点地图绘制覆盖方面的差距。如果取水点地图绘制数据库变得更加完整,且上述障碍得到解决,它还可用于制定更现实的家庭饮用水获取量度以进行监测。