Zillikens M Carola, Conway Joan M
Energy and Protein Nutrition Laboratory, United States Department of Agriculture, Agricultural Research Service, Beltsville, Maryland 20705.
Am J Hum Biol. 1991;3(1):25-32. doi: 10.1002/ajhb.1310030106.
Several differences exist between the body composition of blacks and whites. This study was designed to investigate the applicability of bioelectrical impedance analysis (BIA) in blacks, using prediction equations developed in whites. A multiple regression equation developed on 79 white adults, using deuterium oxide dilution space total body water (D O-TBW) as the reference method, was prospectively applied to 88 blacks aged 19-50 years. Although the regression line of D O-TBW on BIA-TBW was not significantly different from the line of identity (r = 0.98, SEE = 1.71 liters), mean TBW was significantly underestimated by 0.84 liter. Other BIA equations from the literature also underestimated D O-TBW in blacks, except for an equation developed on a mixed black and white population. Multiple regression analysis on the data of the black and white subjects combined showed that race, offered as a separate independent variable, improved the correlation with D O-TBW slightly but significantly (P < 0.01). It was concluded that BIA may be valuable in the assessment of body composition in blacks as well as in whites. In this study a small underestimation of TBW occurred in blacks, using (BIA) equations from whites. This may be due to racial differences in body composition or to factors unrelated to ethnicity.
黑人和白人的身体成分存在一些差异。本研究旨在使用在白人中开发的预测方程,调查生物电阻抗分析(BIA)在黑人中的适用性。一个基于79名白人成年人建立的多元回归方程,以氧化氘稀释空间总体水(D₂O-TBW)作为参考方法,前瞻性地应用于88名年龄在19至50岁的黑人。尽管D₂O-TBW对BIA-TBW的回归线与恒等线无显著差异(r = 0.98,标准误 = 1.71升),但平均TBW被显著低估了0.84升。文献中的其他BIA方程在黑人中也低估了D₂O-TBW,但在一个黑白混合人群中开发的方程除外。对黑人和白人受试者的数据进行的多元回归分析表明,作为一个单独自变量的种族,与D₂O-TBW的相关性略有但显著提高(P < 0.01)。研究得出结论,BIA在评估黑人和白人的身体成分方面可能都有价值。在本研究中,使用白人的(BIA)方程时,黑人的TBW出现了轻微低估。这可能是由于身体成分的种族差异或与种族无关的因素导致的。