Morrens Bert, Den Hond Elly, Schoeters Greet, Coertjens Dries, Colles Ann, Nawrot Tim S, Baeyens Willy, De Henauw Stefaan, Nelen Vera, Loots Ilse
Department of Sociology, Faculty of Social Sciences, University of Antwerp, Sint-Jacobstraat 2, 2000, Antwerp, Belgium.
Provincial Institute for Hygiene, Antwerp, Belgium.
Environ Health. 2017 May 19;16(1):48. doi: 10.1186/s12940-017-0260-2.
Environmental justice research shows how socially disadvantaged groups are more exposed and more vulnerable to environmental pollution. At the same time, these groups are less represented and, thus, less visible in biomedical studies. This socioeconomic participation bias is a form of environmental injustice within research practice itself.
We designed, implemented and evaluated a targeted recruitment strategy to enhance the participation of socially disadvantaged pregnant women in a human biomonitoring study in Belgium. We focused on women of Turkish and Moroccan descent and developed a setup using personal buddies that enabled information transfer about study conditions in the pre-parturition period as well as support and follow-up with questionnaires in the post-parturition period.
We identified four barriers to the participation of women with a vulnerable social and ethnic background which were related to psychosocial and situational factors. Lack of trust in researchers and no perceived study benefits were important personal barriers; the complex study design and difficult self-administered questionnaires were equally significant barriers.
By investing in direct, person-to-person contact with trusted buddies and supported by practical advice about cultural and linguistic sensitivity, it was possible to increase study participation of socially disadvantaged people. Above all, this required openness and flexibility in the mind-set of researchers so that study design and procedures could be better grounded in the experiences and circumstances of underprivileged groups.
环境正义研究表明,社会弱势群体更容易接触到环境污染,且更易受到其影响。与此同时,这些群体在生物医学研究中的代表性较低,因而较少受到关注。这种社会经济参与偏差是研究实践本身存在的一种环境不公正形式。
我们设计、实施并评估了一项有针对性的招募策略,以提高比利时社会弱势孕妇参与一项人体生物监测研究的比例。我们聚焦于土耳其和摩洛哥裔女性,并采用个人伙伴机制,在分娩前阶段传递有关研究情况的信息,并在分娩后阶段通过问卷进行支持和随访。
我们确定了社会和族裔背景脆弱的女性参与研究的四个障碍,这些障碍与心理社会和情境因素有关。对研究人员缺乏信任以及认为研究没有益处是重要的个人障碍;复杂的研究设计和难以自行填写的问卷同样是重大障碍。
通过与值得信赖的伙伴进行直接的人际接触,并辅以关于文化和语言敏感性的实用建议,有可能提高社会弱势群体的研究参与度。最重要的是,这需要研究人员在思维方式上保持开放和灵活,以便研究设计和程序能够更好地基于弱势群体的经验和情况。