Biophysics and Biomedical Modeling Division, U.S. Army Research Institute of Environmental Medicine, Natick, MA 01760, United States.
Pennington Biomedical Research Center, Baton Rouge, LA 70808, United States.
Appetite. 2017 Sep 1;116:389-394. doi: 10.1016/j.appet.2017.05.025. Epub 2017 May 17.
Accurate assessment of dietary intake continues to challenge researchers, especially in field, or non-laboratory settings.
In this study, digital food photography (DFP) methodology was used to assess nutritional intake (NI) of Soldiers participating in the US Army's Ranger Selection and Assessment Program (RASP).
During this high-intensity six-week course, Soldiers complete simulated operational missions, perform various military tasks, and importantly, eating time is severely limited. Therefore, this study provided an opportunity to evaluate the utility of DFP methods for accurate assessment of energy balance in conditions where consumption of large numbers of subjects must be completed in a very short periods of time (≤20 min). NI of 131 male, enlisted Soldiers (21 ± 4 years, 178±7 cm, and 78±8 kg) enrolled in the RASP course was assessed in their garrison dining facility using DFP utilizing visual estimation of pre- and post-meal photos of participant meals concurrently with photos of weighed, standardized portions. Total daily energy expenditure (TDEE) was assessed using doubly-labeled water (HO) in a sub-group of 19 volunteers.
During the study, data loss (i.e., missing meal photos) was less than 5% per meal, and during the visual estimation process discrepancies in food identification averaged less than 10% per meal, while approximately a third of serving size estimations required a third party adjudication prior to finalization and calculation NI.
We conclude that the use of DFP allows an adequately reliable approach for quantifying NI in real-world scenarios involving large numbers of participants who must be assessed very rapidly, and researchers must have a small footprint.
准确评估饮食摄入仍然是研究人员面临的挑战,尤其是在现场或非实验室环境中。
本研究采用数字食物摄影(DFP)方法评估参加美国陆军游骑兵选拔和评估计划(RASP)的士兵的营养摄入量(NI)。
在这个高强度的六周课程中,士兵完成模拟作战任务,执行各种军事任务,重要的是,他们的进食时间非常有限。因此,本研究提供了一个机会,评估 DFP 方法在必须在非常短的时间内(≤20 分钟)完成大量受试者的情况下准确评估能量平衡的实用性。在 RASP 课程中,对 131 名男性入伍士兵(21±4 岁,178±7 厘米,78±8 公斤)在营地餐饮设施中使用 DFP 进行了评估,使用视觉估计参与者餐前和餐后照片中的食物摄入量,同时拍摄称重、标准化的标准份量照片。使用双标记水(HO)在 19 名志愿者的亚组中评估了总每日能量消耗(TDEE)。
在研究过程中,每餐的数据丢失(即缺少餐点照片)少于 5%,在视觉估计过程中,每餐食物识别差异平均少于 10%,而大约三分之一的份量估计需要第三方裁决才能最终确定和计算 NI。
我们得出结论,使用 DFP 可以为在涉及大量必须快速评估的参与者的真实场景中定量评估 NI 提供一种足够可靠的方法,并且研究人员的足迹必须很小。