Rahman Fakhri, Birowo Ponco, Widyahening Indah S, Rasyid Nur
Department of Urology, Dr. Cipto Mangunkusumo National General Hospital, Faculty of Medicine, Universitas Indonesia, Jakarta Pusat, 10430, Indonesia.
Department of Community Medicine, Faculty of Medicine, Universitas Indonesia, Jakarta Pusat, 10310, Indonesia.
F1000Res. 2017 Mar 6;6:220. doi: 10.12688/f1000research.10976.1. eCollection 2017.
Urolithiasis is a disease with high recurrence rate, 30-50% within 5 years. The aim of the present study was to learn the effects of citrus-based products on the urine profile in healthy persons and people with urolithiasis compared to control diet and potassium citrate. A systematic review was performed, which included interventional, prospective observational and retrospective studies, comparing citrus-based therapy with standard diet therapy, mineral water, or potassium citrate. A literature search was conducted using PUBMED, COCHRANE, and Google Scholar with "citrus or lemonade or orange or grapefruit or lime or juice" and "urolithiasis" as search terms. For statistical analysis, a fixed-effects model was conducted when p > 0.05, and random-effects model was conducted when p < 0.05. In total, 135 citations were found through database searching with 10 studies found to be consistent with our selection criteria. However, only 8 studies were included in quantitative analysis, due to data availability. The present study showed a higher increased in urine pH for citrus-based products (mean difference, 0.16; 95% CI 0.01-0.32) and urinary citrate (mean difference, 124.49; 95% CI 80.24-168.74) compared with a control group. However, no differences were found in urine volume, urinary calcium, urinary oxalate, and urinary uric acid. From subgroup analysis, we found that citrus-based products consistently increased urinary citrate level higher than controls in both healthy and urolithiasis populations. Furthermore, there was lower urinary calcium level among people with urolithiasis. Citrus-based products could increase urinary citrate level significantly higher than control. These results should encourage further research to explore citrus-based products as a urolithiasis treatment.
尿石症是一种复发率很高的疾病,5年内复发率为30%-50%。本研究的目的是了解与对照饮食和柠檬酸钾相比,柑橘类产品对健康人和尿石症患者尿液指标的影响。进行了一项系统评价,其中包括干预性、前瞻性观察性和回顾性研究,比较了柑橘类疗法与标准饮食疗法、矿泉水或柠檬酸钾。使用PUBMED、COCHRANE和谷歌学术进行文献检索,搜索词为“柑橘或柠檬水或橙子或葡萄柚或酸橙或果汁”和“尿石症”。进行统计分析时,p>0.05时采用固定效应模型,p<0.05时采用随机效应模型。通过数据库搜索共找到135篇文献,其中10项研究符合我们的纳入标准。然而,由于数据可得性,只有8项研究纳入了定量分析。本研究表明,与对照组相比,柑橘类产品使尿液pH值升高幅度更大(平均差异为0.16;95%可信区间为0.01-0.32),尿枸橼酸盐升高(平均差异为124.49;95%可信区间为80.24-168.74)。然而,尿量以及尿钙、草酸和尿酸水平没有差异。亚组分析发现,在健康人群和尿石症患者中柑橘类产品使尿枸橼酸盐水平持续高于对照组。此外,尿石症患者的尿钙水平较低。柑橘类产品可使尿枸橼酸盐水平显著高于对照组。这些结果应鼓励进一步研究,以探索将柑橘类产品作为尿石症的一种治疗方法。