Kunkel Amber, Lewnard Joseph A, Pitzer Virginia E, Cohen Ted
Department of Epidemiology, Harvard T. H. Chan School of Public Health, Boston, Massachusetts, USA
Department of Epidemiology of Microbial Diseases, Yale School of Public Health, New Haven, Connecticut, USA.
Antimicrob Agents Chemother. 2017 Jul 25;61(8). doi: 10.1128/AAC.00026-17. Print 2017 Aug.
More than 5 years after a United Nations peacekeeping battalion introduced cholera to Haiti, over 150,000 peacekeepers continue to be deployed annually from countries where cholera is endemic. The United Nations has thus far declined to provide antimicrobial chemoprophylaxis to peacekeepers, a policy based largely on concerns that the risks of drug resistance generation and spread would outweigh the potential benefits of preventing future cholera importations. In this study, we sought to better understand the relative benefits and risks of cholera chemoprophylaxis for peacekeepers in terms of antibiotic resistance. Using a stochastic model to quantify the potential impact of chemoprophylaxis on importation and transmission of drug-resistant and drug-sensitive , we found that chemoprophylaxis would decrease the probability of cholera importation but would increase the expected number of drug-resistant infections if an importation event were to occur. Despite this potential increase, we found that at least 10 drug-sensitive infections would likely be averted per excess drug-resistant infection under a wide range of assumptions about the underlying prevalence of drug resistance and risk of acquired resistance. Given these findings, policymakers should reconsider whether the potential resistance risks of providing antimicrobial chemoprophylaxis to peacekeepers are sufficient to outweigh the anticipated benefits.
在一个联合国维和营将霍乱引入海地五年多后,每年仍有超过15万名维和人员从霍乱流行国家被部署到海地。联合国迄今拒绝为维和人员提供抗菌化学预防,这一政策主要基于对产生和传播耐药性的风险将超过预防未来霍乱输入的潜在益处的担忧。在本研究中,我们试图从抗生素耐药性方面更好地理解霍乱化学预防对维和人员的相对益处和风险。使用一个随机模型来量化化学预防对耐药和敏感霍乱输入及传播的潜在影响,我们发现化学预防会降低霍乱输入的概率,但如果发生输入事件,会增加耐药感染的预期数量。尽管有这种潜在增加,但我们发现,在关于耐药性的潜在流行率和获得性耐药风险的广泛假设下,每多一例耐药感染,至少可能避免10例敏感感染。鉴于这些发现,政策制定者应重新考虑为维和人员提供抗菌化学预防的潜在耐药风险是否足以超过预期益处。