Kent Katherine, Charlton Karen
a Faculty of Health , University of Tasmania , Tasmania , Australia.
b Faculty of Science, Medicine and Health , University of Wollongong , Wollongong , Australia.
J Nutr Gerontol Geriatr. 2017 Apr-Sep;36(2-3):134-147. doi: 10.1080/21551197.2017.1321080. Epub 2017 May 23.
There is a large burden on researchers and participants when attempting to accurately measure dietary flavonoid intake using dietary assessment. Minimizing participant and researcher burden when collecting dietary data may improve the validity of the results, especially in older adults with cognitive impairment. A short 14-item food frequency questionnaire (FFQ) to measure flavonoid intake, and flavonoid subclasses (anthocyanins, flavan-3-ols, flavones, flavonols, and flavanones) was developed and assessed for validity and reproducibility against a 24-hour recall. Older adults with mild-moderate dementia (n = 49) attended two interviews 12 weeks apart. With the assistance of a family carer, a 24-h recall was collected at the first interview, and the flavonoid FFQ was interviewer-administered at both time-points. Validity and reproducibility was assessed using the Wilcoxon signed-rank sum test, Spearman's correlation coefficient, Bland-Altman Plots, and Cohen's kappa. Mean flavonoid intake was determined (FFQ1 = 795 ± 492.7 mg/day, 24-h recall = 515.6 ± 384.3 mg/day). Tests of validity indicated the FFQ was better at estimating total flavonoid intake than individual flavonoid subclasses compared with the 24-h recall. There was a significant difference in total flavonoid intake estimates between the FFQ and the 24-h recall (Wilcoxon signed-rank sum p < 0.001; Bland-Altman plots indicated large bias and wide limits of agreement), but they were well correlated (Spearman's correlation coefficient r = 0.74, p < 0.001; Cohen's kappa κ = 0.292, p < 0.001). The FFQ showed good reproducibility, with a small mean percentage difference (12.6%). The Wilcoxon signed-rank sum test showed no significant difference, Spearman's correlation coefficient indicated excellent reliability (r = 0.75, p < 0.001), Bland-Altman plots visually showed small, nonsignificant bias and wide limits of agreement, and Cohen's kappa indicated fair agreement (κ = 0.429, p < 0.001). A 14-item FFQ developed to easily measure flavonoid intake in older adults with dementia demonstrates fair validity against a 24-h recall and good reproducibility.
在尝试通过饮食评估准确测量膳食黄酮类化合物摄入量时,研究人员和参与者面临着巨大的负担。在收集饮食数据时尽量减少参与者和研究人员的负担,可能会提高结果的有效性,尤其是在患有认知障碍的老年人中。我们开发了一份简短的包含14个条目的食物频率问卷(FFQ)来测量黄酮类化合物摄入量以及黄酮类化合物亚类(花青素、黄烷-3-醇、黄酮、黄酮醇和黄烷酮),并针对24小时膳食回顾法评估了其有效性和可重复性。患有轻度至中度痴呆症的老年人(n = 49)参加了两次间隔12周的访谈。在家庭护理人员的协助下,在第一次访谈时收集了24小时膳食回顾,并且在两个时间点均由访谈者进行黄酮类化合物FFQ的调查。使用Wilcoxon符号秩和检验、Spearman相关系数、Bland-Altman图和Cohen's kappa评估有效性和可重复性。确定了平均黄酮类化合物摄入量(FFQ1 = 795 ± 492.7毫克/天,24小时膳食回顾 = 515.6 ± 384.3毫克/天)。有效性测试表明,与24小时膳食回顾相比,FFQ在估计总黄酮类化合物摄入量方面比单个黄酮类化合物亚类表现更好。FFQ和24小时膳食回顾之间在总黄酮类化合物摄入量估计上存在显著差异(Wilcoxon符号秩和检验p < 0.001;Bland-Altman图显示存在较大偏差和较宽的一致性界限),但它们具有良好的相关性(Spearman相关系数r = 0.74,p < 0.001;Cohen's kappa κ = 0.292,p < 0.001)。FFQ显示出良好的可重复性,平均百分比差异较小(12.6%)。Wilcoxon符号秩和检验显示无显著差异,Spearman相关系数表明具有出色的可靠性(r = 0.75,p < 0.001),Bland-Altman图直观地显示出较小的、不显著的偏差和较宽的一致性界限,Cohen's kappa表明一致性尚可(κ = 0.429,p < 0.001)。为轻松测量患有痴呆症的老年人的黄酮类化合物摄入量而开发的一份包含14个条目的FFQ相对24小时膳食回顾法显示出尚可的有效性和良好的可重复性。