Carter Gerald G, Farine Damien R, Wilkinson Gerald S
Smithsonian Tropical Research Institute, Balboa, Ancón, Panama
Department of Collective Behaviour, Max Planck Institute for Ornithology, Konstanz, Germany.
Biol Lett. 2017 May;13(5). doi: 10.1098/rsbl.2017.0112.
Helping kin or nonkin can provide direct fitness benefits, but helping kin also benefits indirect fitness. Why then should organisms invest in cooperative partnerships with nonkin, if kin relationships are available and more beneficial? One explanation is that a kin-limited support network is too small and risky. Even if additional weaker partnerships reduce immediate net cooperative returns, individuals extending cooperation to nonkin can maintain a larger social network which reduces the potential costs associated with losing a primary cooperation partner. Just as financial or evolutionary bet-hedging strategies can reduce risk, investing in of social relationships at the expense of relationship ('social bet-hedging') can reduce the risks posed by unpredictable social environments. Here, we provide evidence for social bet-hedging in food-sharing vampire bats. When we experimentally removed a key food-sharing partner, females that previously fed a greater number of unrelated females suffered a smaller reduction in food received. Females that invested in more nonkin bonds did not do better under normal conditions, but they coped better with partner loss. Hence, loss of a key partner revealed the importance of weaker nonkin bonds. Social bet-hedging can have important implications for social network structure by influencing how individuals form relationships.
帮助亲属或非亲属都能带来直接的适应性益处,但帮助亲属也有利于间接适应性。那么,如果亲属关系可行且更有益,生物为何还要投资与非亲属的合作关系呢?一种解释是,亲属有限的支持网络规模太小且风险太大。即使额外的较弱合作关系会降低即时的净合作回报,但将合作扩展到非亲属的个体可以维持更大的社交网络,这能降低因失去主要合作伙伴而产生的潜在成本。正如金融或进化中的风险对冲策略可以降低风险一样,以牺牲关系的质量为代价来投资社交关系的多样性(“社交风险对冲”)可以降低不可预测的社会环境带来的风险。在此,我们为吸血蝙蝠食物共享中的社交风险对冲提供了证据。当我们通过实验移除一个关键的食物共享伙伴时,之前喂养过更多非亲属雌性蝙蝠的雌性蝙蝠所获得的食物减少幅度较小。在正常情况下,投资于更多非亲属关系的雌性蝙蝠表现并不更好,但它们在应对伙伴损失方面表现更佳。因此,关键伙伴的丧失揭示了较弱的非亲属关系的重要性。社交风险对冲可能会通过影响个体建立关系的方式,对社交网络结构产生重要影响。