Black I, Bowie P
NHS Education for Scotland, Glasgow, UK.
Healthcare Improvement Scotland, Edinburgh, UK.
Br Dent J. 2017 May 26;222(10):782-788. doi: 10.1038/sj.bdj.2017.456.
Introduction The 'never event' concept is often used in secondary care and refers to an agreed list of patient safety incidents that 'should not happen if the necessary preventative measures are in place'. Such an intervention may raise awareness of patient safety issues and inform team learning and system improvements in primary care dentistry.Objective To identify and develop a candidate never event list for primary care dentistry.Methods A literature review, eight workshops with dental practitioners and a modified Delphi with 'expert' groups were used to identify and agree candidate never events.Results Two-hundred and fifty dental practitioners suggested 507 never events, reduced to 27 distinct possibilities grouped across seven themes. Most frequently occurring themes were: 'checking medical history and prescribing' (119, 23.5%) and 'infection control and decontamination' (71, 14%). 'Experts' endorsed nine candidate never event statements with one graded as 'extreme risk' (failure to check past medical history) and four as 'high risk' (for example, extracting wrong tooth).Conclusion Consensus on a preliminary list of never events was developed. This is the first known attempt to develop this approach and an important step in determining its value to patient safety. Further work is necessary to develop the utility of this method.
引言 “零事故” 概念常用于二级医疗保健领域,指的是一份商定的患者安全事件清单,即 “如果采取了必要的预防措施,这些事件就不应发生”。这样的干预措施可能会提高对患者安全问题的认识,并为基层牙科医疗中的团队学习和系统改进提供信息。
目的 确定并制定一份基层牙科医疗的候选零事故清单。
方法 通过文献综述、与牙科从业者举办的八次研讨会以及与 “专家” 小组进行的改良德尔菲法来确定并商定候选零事故事件。
结果 250名牙科从业者提出了507起零事故事件,归纳为七个主题下的27种不同可能性。出现频率最高的主题是:“检查病史和开处方”(119起,占23.5%)和“感染控制与消毒”(71起,占14%)。“专家” 认可了九条候选零事故事件陈述,其中一条被评为 “极高风险”(未检查既往病史),四条被评为 “高风险”(例如,拔错牙)。
结论 就零事故事件的初步清单达成了共识。这是已知的首次尝试采用这种方法,也是确定其对患者安全价值的重要一步。有必要开展进一步工作以提高该方法的实用性。