Lawton Teri, Shelley-Tremblay John
Cognitive Neuroscience Research and Remediation, Perception Dynamics InstituteEncinitas, CA, USA.
Department of Psychology, University of South AlabamaMobile, AL, USA.
Front Hum Neurosci. 2017 May 15;11:236. doi: 10.3389/fnhum.2017.00236. eCollection 2017.
The purpose of this study was to determine whether neurotraining to discriminate a moving test pattern relative to a stationary background, figure-ground discrimination, improves vision and cognitive functioning in dyslexics, as well as typically-developing normal students. We predict that improving the speed and sensitivity of figure-ground movement discrimination ( neurotraining) acts to remediate visual timing deficits in the dorsal stream, thereby improving processing speed, reading fluency, and the executive control functions of attention and working memory in both dyslexic and normal students who had neurotraining more than in those students who had no neurotraining. This prediction was evaluated by measuring whether dyslexic and normal students improved on standardized tests of cognitive skills following neurotraining exercises, more than following computer-based guided reading ( ()). The neurotraining used in this study was visually-based training designed to improve magnocellular function at both low and high levels in the dorsal stream: the input to the executive control networks coding working memory and attention. This approach represents a paradigm shift from the phonologically-based treatment for dyslexia, which concentrates on high-level speech and reading areas. This randomized controlled-validation study was conducted by training the entire second and third grade classrooms (42 students) for 30 min twice a week before guided reading. Standardized tests were administered at the beginning and end of 12-weeks of intervention training to evaluate improvements in academic skills. Only movement-discrimination training remediated both low-level visual timing deficits and high-level cognitive functioning, including selective and sustained attention, reading fluency and working memory for both dyslexic and normal students. Remediating visual timing deficits in the dorsal stream revealed the causal role of visual movement discrimination training in improving high-level cognitive functions such as attention, reading acquisition and working memory. This study supports the hypothesis that faulty timing in synchronizing the activity of magnocellular with parvocellular visual pathways in the dorsal stream is a fundamental cause of dyslexia and being at-risk for reading problems in normal students, and argues against the assumption that reading deficiencies in dyslexia are caused by phonological or language deficits, requiring a paradigm shift from phonologically-based treatment of dyslexia to a visually-based treatment. This study shows that visual movement-discrimination can be used not only to diagnose dyslexia early, but also for its successful treatment, so that reading problems do not prevent children from readily learning.
本研究的目的是确定针对在静止背景中辨别移动测试图案的神经训练(图形-背景辨别)是否能改善阅读障碍者以及发育正常的普通学生的视力和认知功能。我们预测,提高图形-背景运动辨别的速度和敏感度(神经训练)有助于纠正背侧视觉通路中的视觉时间缺陷,从而提高阅读障碍学生和普通学生的处理速度、阅读流畅性以及注意力和工作记忆的执行控制功能,接受神经训练的学生的改善程度会高于未接受神经训练的学生。通过测量阅读障碍学生和普通学生在接受神经训练练习后,与接受基于计算机的引导阅读()后相比,在认知技能标准化测试中的表现是否有所提高,来评估这一预测。本研究中使用的神经训练是基于视觉的训练,旨在改善背侧视觉通路中低水平和高水平的大细胞功能:这是执行控制网络对工作记忆和注意力进行编码的输入。这种方法代表了一种从基于语音的诵读困难治疗方法的范式转变,后者主要集中在高水平的语言和阅读区域。这项随机对照验证研究是通过在引导阅读前,对整个二年级和三年级班级(42名学生)进行每周两次、每次30分钟的训练来进行的。在为期12周的干预训练开始和结束时进行标准化测试,以评估学业技能的提高情况。只有运动辨别训练纠正了阅读障碍学生和普通学生的低水平视觉时间缺陷和高水平认知功能,包括选择性和持续性注意力、阅读流畅性和工作记忆。纠正背侧视觉通路中的视觉时间缺陷揭示了视觉运动辨别训练在改善注意力、阅读习得和工作记忆等高水平认知功能方面的因果作用。本研究支持这样一种假设,即背侧视觉通路中大细胞与小细胞视觉通路活动同步时的时间错误是诵读困难的根本原因,也是普通学生出现阅读问题的风险因素,并反对诵读困难中的阅读缺陷是由语音或语言缺陷引起的假设,这需要从基于语音的诵读困难治疗方法向基于视觉的治疗方法进行范式转变。本研究表明,视觉运动辨别不仅可用于早期诊断诵读困难,还可用于其成功治疗,从而使阅读问题不会妨碍儿童轻松学习。