Leibniz Institute for Science and Mathematics Education, Kiel, Germany.
Humboldt-University, Berlin, Germany.
J Pers. 2018 Jun;86(3):481-497. doi: 10.1111/jopy.12330. Epub 2017 Aug 4.
When considering that social inclusion is a basic human need, it makes sense that self-esteem is fueled by social feedback and the sense of being liked by others. This is particularly true with respect to early adolescence, when peers become increasingly important. In the current article, we tested which components of social inclusion are particularly beneficial for the development of self-esteem by differentiating between intrapersonal components (i.e., self-perceptions of social inclusion) and interpersonal components (i.e., perceiver and target effects of liking).
Using longitudinal data from 2,281 fifth graders and 1,766 eighth graders (TRAIN; Jonkmann et al., 2013), we tested mean-level self-esteem development and the role of intrapersonal components in this development. Using classroom round-robin data on liking from subsamples of 846 (689) fifth-(eighth-)grade students nested in 46 (39) classes, we tested effects of interpersonal relationship components on self-esteem development in the classroom context.
The three major findings demonstrated, first, no consistent trends in mean levels of self-esteem in early to middle adolescence; second, constant positive effects of intrapersonal components between students and within students across time; and third, no stable effects of interpersonal components.
The discussion highlights the role of intrapersonal components and the methodological challenges of our study.
当考虑到社会包容是人类的基本需求时,自尊心是由社会反馈和被他人喜欢的感觉所驱动的,这是有道理的。这在青少年早期尤其如此,因为此时同龄人变得越来越重要。在本文中,我们通过区分人际成分(即自我感知的社会包容)和人际成分(即喜欢的感知者和目标效应),测试了社会包容的哪些成分对自尊心的发展特别有益。
使用来自 2281 名五年级学生和 1766 名八年级学生的纵向数据(TRAIN;Jonkmann 等人,2013 年),我们测试了自尊的平均水平发展以及人际成分在这一发展中的作用。使用来自 46 个(39 个)班级的 846 名(689 名)五年级(八年级)学生的班级轮询数据,我们测试了人际关系成分对课堂环境中自尊发展的影响。
三个主要发现表明,首先,在青少年早期到中期,自尊的平均水平没有一致的趋势;其次,学生之间和学生内部的人际成分在整个时间内都有积极的影响;第三,没有稳定的人际成分影响。
讨论强调了人际成分的作用和我们研究的方法学挑战。