Magro Malosso Elena Rita, Saccone Gabriele, Simonetti Biagio, Squillante Massimo, Berghella Vincenzo
a Department of Health Science, Division of Pediatrics, Obstetrics and Gynecology , Careggi Hospital University of Florence , Florence , Italy.
b Department of Neuroscience, Reproductive Sciences and Dentistry, School of Medicine , University of Naples "Federico II" , Naples , Italy.
J Matern Fetal Neonatal Med. 2018 Sep;31(18):2463-2467. doi: 10.1080/14767058.2017.1344963. Epub 2017 Jul 6.
A recent large meta-analysis concluded that prior surgical abortion was an independent risk factor for spontaneous preterm birth (PTB), while they found no significant correlation between PTB and medical abortion.
To evaluate the potential impact of changes in US abortion rates and practices on US incidence of PTB rate.
This was an epidemiologic analysis of legal abortion and PTB data in the USA from 2003 to 2012. Birth data (annual total birth, annual number and incidence of PTB, defined as PTB <37 weeks) are from National Vital Statistics Reports from the National Center for Health Statistics, Center of Disease Control and Prevention (CDC). Abortion data were collected using Abortion Surveillance provided by the CDC. Abortion incidence was reported overall, and by type: surgical, medical method and procedures reported as "other" such as intrauterine instillation and hysterectomy/hysterotomy. To test for the trend of abortion and of PTB over time, we used the chi-squared test for trend. The primary outcome of our study was the correlation trend analysis between abortion rate and PTB rate. Pearson correlation test was used. A two-tailed p value of 0.05 or less was considered significant.
From 2003 to 2012 there were 41 206 315 births in USA, of which 5 042 982 (12.2%) were <37 weeks. The PTB rate declined significantly from 12.3% in 2003 to 11.5% in 2012 (p value test for trend <.04). Out of the 6 122 649 legal abortions, reported by type of procedure, performed from 2003 to 2012 in USA, 5 132 789 were surgical abortion (82.8%) and 860 288 (14.0%) were medical. Chi-squared test for trend showed that the rate of surgical abortion significantly decreased from 88.9 to 78.0% (p < .01) while the rate of medical abortion significantly increased from 7.9 to 21.9% (p < .01) from 2003 to 2012, respectively. The rate of PTB was correlated with the rate of medical abortion (p = .01) and of surgical abortion (p = .02) over time. The higher the surgical abortion rate, the higher the incidence of PTB (Pearson correlation 0.712); the higher the medical abortion rate, the lower the incidence of PTB (Pearson correlation -0.731).
Recent changes in abortion practices may be associated with the current decrease in US incidence of PTB. Further study on the effect of surgical versus medical abortion is warranted regarding a possible effect on the incidence of PTB.
最近一项大型荟萃分析得出结论,既往手术流产是自发性早产(PTB)的独立危险因素,而他们发现PTB与药物流产之间无显著相关性。
评估美国流产率和流产方式的变化对美国PTB发生率的潜在影响。
这是一项对2003年至2012年美国合法流产和PTB数据的流行病学分析。出生数据(年度总出生数、PTB的年度数量和发生率,定义为PTB<37周)来自疾病控制和预防中心(CDC)国家卫生统计中心的《国家生命统计报告》。流产数据使用CDC提供的流产监测数据收集。总体报告了流产发生率,并按类型报告:手术流产、药物流产方法以及报告为“其他”的程序,如子宫内灌注和子宫切除术/子宫切开术。为了检验流产和PTB随时间的趋势,我们使用了趋势卡方检验。我们研究的主要结果是流产率与PTB率之间的相关性趋势分析。使用Pearson相关检验。双侧p值小于或等于0.05被认为具有统计学意义。
2003年至2012年美国共有41206315例出生,其中5042982例(12.2%)为<37周。PTB率从2003年的12.3%显著下降至2012年的11.5%(趋势检验p值<.04)。在美国2003年至2012年报告的6122649例合法流产中,按手术程序类型划分,5132789例为手术流产(82.8%),860288例(14.0%)为药物流产。趋势卡方检验显示,从2003年至2012年,手术流产率从88.9%显著下降至78.0%(p<.01),而药物流产率从7.9%显著上升至21.9%(p<.01)。随着时间的推移,PTB率与药物流产率(p = 0.01)和手术流产率(p = 0.02)相关。手术流产率越高,PTB发生率越高(Pearson相关系数0.712);药物流产率越高,PTB发生率越低(Pearson相关系数-0.731)。
近期流产方式的变化可能与美国目前PTB发生率的下降有关。关于手术流产与药物流产对PTB发生率可能产生的影响,有必要进一步研究。