Ziegler Stine, van den Bussche Hendrik, Römer Farina, Krause-Solberg Lea, Scherer Martin
Dtsch Med Wochenschr. 2017 Jun;142(12):e74-e82. doi: 10.1055/s-0043-101860. Epub 2017 Jun 21.
We investigated the preferences of medical residents in Germany with regard to future working place (hospital or private practice) and position (employment/self-employment in private practice; resp. specialist/senior or chief physician in the hospital). This is analysed in a gender comparative perspective, including the influence of parenthood. Annual postal surveys among graduates of seven medical faculties in Germany from their last year ("Practical Year") until after four years of postgraduate training. The return rate at baseline was 48 % and the four surveys after reached rates from 85 % up. In all samples about two thirds were women, which corresponds to the actual gender differentiation in under- and postgraduate training. Descriptive statistics and regression analyses were performed. Compared to private practice the hospital is clearly preferred, although the attraction of hospital jobs decreased over the years. The decision for or against the hospital is connected to the discipline. Working in private practice is seen as possibility for part time work. Men prefer self-employment whereas women prefer to work under an employment contract. In the hospital, male doctors prefer to work in leading positions. Those positions are associated with full-time work. Leadership training especially takes place in university hospitals. Three trends are recognized: Reluctance against leading positions, growing interest for part time work and rising popularity of work as an employee in private practice. Those trends can be understood as a rejection of traditional professional role models. The realization of these preferences is easily feasible because of the current labour market situation. Therefore, emerging problems have to be faced in another way. A change of gender-typical role models was rarely detected.
我们调查了德国住院医师对未来工作地点(医院或私人诊所)和职位(私人诊所的雇佣/自主执业;分别对应医院的专科医生/高级或主任医师)的偏好。从性别比较的角度对此进行了分析,包括为人父母的影响。对德国七个医学院校的毕业生从最后一年(“实习年”)到毕业后四年进行年度邮寄调查。基线时的回复率为48%,之后的四次调查回复率达到85%及以上。在所有样本中,约三分之二为女性,这与本科及研究生培训中的实际性别差异相符。进行了描述性统计和回归分析。与私人诊所相比,医院显然更受青睐,尽管医院工作的吸引力多年来有所下降。选择去医院还是不去医院与学科相关。在私人诊所工作被视为兼职工作的一种可能性。男性更喜欢自主执业,而女性更喜欢签订雇佣合同工作。在医院里,男医生更喜欢担任领导职位。这些职位与全职工作相关。领导力培训尤其在大学医院进行。识别出三种趋势:对领导职位的抵触、对兼职工作兴趣的增加以及在私人诊所受雇工作的受欢迎程度上升。这些趋势可被理解为对传统职业榜样的摒弃。由于当前劳动力市场状况,这些偏好的实现很容易做到。因此,必须以其他方式面对新出现的问题。很少发现性别典型榜样的变化。