Skinner Asheley Cockrell, Payne Keith, Perrin Andrew J, Panter Abigail T, Howard Janna B, Bardone-Cone Anna, Bulik Cynthia M, Steiner Michael J, Perrin Eliana M
Department of Medicine, Duke University, Durham, North Carolina;
Duke Clinical Research Institute, Durham, North Carolina.
Pediatrics. 2017 Jul;140(1). doi: 10.1542/peds.2016-3936.
Assess implicit weight bias in children 9 to 11 years old.
Implicit weight bias was measured in children ages 9 to 11 ( = 114) by using the Affect Misattribution Procedure. Participants were shown a test image of a child for 350 milliseconds followed by a meaningless fractal (200 milliseconds), and then they were asked to rate the fractal image as "good" or "bad." We used 9 image pairs matched on age, race, sex, and activity but differing by weight of the child. Implicit bias was the difference between positive ratings for fractals preceded by an image of a healthy-weight child and positive ratings for fractals preceded by an image of an overweight child.
On average, 64% of abstract fractals shown after pictures of healthy-weight children were rated as "good," compared with 59% of those shown after pictures of overweight children, reflecting an overall implicit bias rate of 5.4% against overweight children ( < .001). Healthy-weight participants showed greater implicit bias than over- and underweight participants (7.9%, 1.4%, and 0.3% respectively; = .049).
Implicit bias toward overweight individuals is evident in children aged 9 to 11 years with a magnitude of implicit bias (5.4%) similar to that in studies of implicit racial bias among adults.
评估9至11岁儿童的隐性体重偏见。
采用情感错误归因程序对9至11岁(n = 114)的儿童进行隐性体重偏见测量。向参与者展示一张儿童测试图像350毫秒,随后展示一张无意义的分形图(200毫秒),然后要求他们将分形图评为“好”或“坏”。我们使用了9对在年龄、种族、性别和活动方面匹配但儿童体重不同的图像对。隐性偏见是指在健康体重儿童图像之后出现的分形图的正面评价与超重儿童图像之后出现的分形图的正面评价之间的差异。
平均而言,在健康体重儿童图片之后展示的抽象分形图中,64%被评为“好”,而在超重儿童图片之后展示的分形图中,这一比例为59%,这反映出对超重儿童的总体隐性偏见率为5.4%(P < .001)。健康体重的参与者表现出比超重和体重过轻的参与者更大的隐性偏见(分别为7.9%、1.4%和0.3%;P = .049)。
9至11岁儿童对超重个体存在明显的隐性偏见,其隐性偏见程度(5.4%)与成人隐性种族偏见研究中的程度相似。