Lee Seung Yong, Jeon Dae-Geun, Cho Wan Hyeong, Song Won Seok, Kong Chang-Bae, Kim Bum Suk
Department of Orthopedic Surgery, Korea Cancer Center Hospital, Seoul, Republic of Korea.
Sarcoma. 2017;2017:9710964. doi: 10.1155/2017/9710964. Epub 2017 Jun 4.
Among various types of composite biological reconstruction, pasteurized autograft-prosthesis composite (PPC) is popular when allograft is unavailable. Previous limited cohort study indicated result comparable to tumor prosthesis. However, as case number and follow-up increase, we experienced more complications than anticipated. We questioned the usefulness of PPC as a viable reconstructive option.
We reviewed 142 PPCs and analyzed overall and location-related survival and factors associated with the failure of PPC.
Twenty-year survival rate of 142 PPCs was 39.8 ± 10.0%. Fifty-two (36.6%) of 142 PPCs showed failure. Among various locations, the proximal femur showed best survival: 78.0 ± 9.9%. Final status of the 52 failed PPCs was modular tumor prosthesis in 23 (43%), arthrodesis in 11 (21%), pseudarthrosis in 7 (13%), amputation in 7 (13%), and allograft-prosthesis composite in 4 (8%). Tumor volume > 200 cc ( = 0.001), pasteurization length ≤ 10 cm ( = 0.002), male sex ( = 0.02), and locations in pelvis or tibia ( = 0.029) were poor prognostic factors.
Long-term survival of PPCs was below expectations. Despite the complexity of the procedure, there is little survival gain over tumor prosthesis. PPC may be indicated when a modular prosthesis is not readily available.
在各种类型的复合生物重建中,当同种异体移植不可用时,经巴氏消毒的自体移植-假体复合物(PPC)很受欢迎。先前有限的队列研究表明其结果与肿瘤假体相当。然而,随着病例数量的增加和随访时间的延长,我们遇到了比预期更多的并发症。我们质疑PPC作为一种可行的重建选择的实用性。
我们回顾了142例PPC,并分析了其总体和部位相关的生存率以及与PPC失败相关的因素。
142例PPC的20年生存率为39.8±10.0%。142例PPC中有52例(36.6%)出现失败。在各个部位中,股骨近端的生存率最佳:78.0±9.9%。52例失败的PPC的最终状态为模块化肿瘤假体23例(43%),关节融合术11例(21%),假关节形成7例(13%),截肢7例(13%),同种异体移植-假体复合物4例(8%)。肿瘤体积>200 cc(P = 0.001)、巴氏消毒长度≤10 cm(P = 0.002)、男性(P = 0.02)以及骨盆或胫骨部位(P = 0.029)是预后不良因素。
PPC的长期生存率低于预期。尽管手术复杂,但与肿瘤假体相比,生存率提高甚微。当模块化假体难以获得时,可考虑使用PPC。