Lorentzen Åslaug R, Forselv Kristine J N, Helgeland Geir, Salvesen Rigmor E, Sand Geir, Flemmen Heidi Ø, Bø Margrete H, Nordaa Ludmila, Roos Anna K, Jim Marion W, Owe Jone F, Nyquist Kaja B, Schüler Stephan, Eikeland Randi, Mygland Åse, Ljøstad Unn
Department of Neurology, Sørlandet Hospital Trust, PO Box 416, 4604, Kristiansand, Norway.
The Norwegian National Advisory Unit on Tick-Borne Diseases, Arendal, Norway.
J Neurol. 2017 Jul;264(7):1506-1510. doi: 10.1007/s00415-017-8559-z. Epub 2017 Jul 4.
Evidence-based guidelines, published in 2010, equate the efficacy of oral and intravenous antibiotics and recommend treatment duration of 2 weeks in early Lyme neuroborreliosis (LNB) without encephalitis or myelitis. Further, the Norwegian health authorities give a general advice to choose oral rather than intravenous administration when proven effective, due to lower costs, fewer risks, and reduced patient inconvenience. In this study we aimed to chart LNB treatment practice in Norway and compare it to these recommendations. Adult patients diagnosed with definite LNB between 2007 and 2013 in 11 different hospitals in the four health regions in Norway were invited to answer a questionnaire regarding duration and administration of antibiotic treatment. A total of 253 patients answered. Median age at diagnosis was 59 years (range 19-83), and 125 (49%) were women. Duration of treatment was 1 week in 7 (3%) patients, 2 weeks in 81 (32%), 3 weeks in 62 (25%), 4 weeks in 48 (19%), 5 weeks in 12 (5%), ≥6 weeks in 29 (12%), and unknown in 14 (6%). Treatment was given orally in 77 (30%) patients, intravenously in 110 (44%), both orally and intravenously in 65 (26%), and unknown in one. Treatment practices differed between the health regions (p = 0.002). During the study period, there were no significant time trend neither with respect to proportion of patients treated for only 2 weeks (OR 0.899, p = 0.109) nor with respect to proportion of patients treated exclusively with oral antibiotics (OR 1.131, p = 0.074). In conclusion, there seem to be a gap between evidence-based recommendations and treatment practice of LNB in Norway.
2010年发布的循证指南认为口服抗生素和静脉注射抗生素疗效相当,并建议在无脑炎或脊髓炎的早期莱姆病神经螺旋体病(LNB)中治疗疗程为2周。此外,挪威卫生当局给出一般性建议,在证明有效的情况下,由于成本较低、风险较少且给患者带来的不便减少,应选择口服而非静脉注射给药。在本研究中,我们旨在梳理挪威LNB的治疗实践情况,并将其与这些建议进行比较。邀请了2007年至2013年期间在挪威四个卫生区域的11家不同医院被诊断为确诊LNB的成年患者回答一份关于抗生素治疗疗程和给药方式的问卷。共有253名患者作答。诊断时的中位年龄为59岁(范围19 - 83岁),125名(49%)为女性。7名(3%)患者的治疗疗程为1周,81名(32%)为2周,62名(25%)为3周,48名(19%)为4周,12名(5%)为5周,29名(12%)为≥6周,14名(6%)未知。77名(30%)患者接受口服治疗,110名(44%)接受静脉注射治疗,65名(26%)接受口服和静脉注射两种方式治疗,1名未知。各卫生区域的治疗实践存在差异(p = 0.002)。在研究期间,无论是仅接受2周治疗的患者比例(比值比0.899,p = 0.109)还是仅接受口服抗生素治疗的患者比例(比值比1.131,p = 0.074),均无显著的时间趋势。总之,挪威LNB的循证建议与治疗实践之间似乎存在差距。