Roy Subhradeep, Abaid Nicole
Department of Biomedical Engineering and Mechanics (MC 0219), 495 Old Turner Street, Virginia Tech, Blacksburg, VA 24061, USA.
R Soc Open Sci. 2017 Jun 7;4(6):170130. doi: 10.1098/rsos.170130. eCollection 2017 Jun.
Understanding how people form opinions and make decisions is a complex phenomenon that depends on both personal practices and interactions. Recent availability of real-world data has enabled quantitative analysis of opinion formation, which illuminates phenomena that impact physical and social sciences. Public policies exemplify complex opinion formation spanning individual and population scales, and a timely example is the legalization of same-sex marriage in the United States. Here, we seek to understand how this issue captures the relationship between state-laws and Senate representatives subject to geographical and ideological factors. Using distance-based correlations, we study how physical proximity and state-government ideology may be used to extract patterns in state-law adoption and senatorial support of same-sex marriage. Results demonstrate that proximal states have similar opinion dynamics in both state-laws and senators' opinions, and states with similar state-government ideology have analogous senators' opinions. Moreover, senators' opinions drive state-laws with a time lag. Thus, change in opinion not only results from negotiations among individuals, but also reflects inherent spatial and political similarities and temporal delays. We build a social impact model of state-law adoption in light of these results, which predicts the evolution of state-laws legalizing same-sex marriage over the last three decades.
理解人们如何形成观点并做出决策是一个复杂的现象,它既取决于个人行为,也取决于人际互动。近期真实世界数据的可得性使得对观点形成进行定量分析成为可能,这揭示了影响自然科学和社会科学的各种现象。公共政策体现了跨越个人和群体层面的复杂观点形成过程,一个适时的例子就是美国同性婚姻合法化。在此,我们试图理解这个问题是如何体现受地理和意识形态因素影响的州法律与参议院代表之间的关系的。利用基于距离的相关性,我们研究地理 proximity 和州政府意识形态如何被用于提取州法律采纳和参议院对同性婚姻支持方面的模式。结果表明,相邻各州在州法律和参议员观点方面具有相似的观点动态,而具有相似州政府意识形态的各州具有类似的参议员观点。此外,参议员的观点会滞后推动州法律的变化。因此,观点的变化不仅源于个体之间的协商,还反映了内在的空间和政治相似性以及时间延迟。基于这些结果,我们构建了一个州法律采纳的社会影响模型,该模型预测了过去三十年同性婚姻合法化州法律的演变。