Pitkänen Minna, Kallioniemi Elisa, Julkunen Petro, Nazarova Maria, Nieminen Jaakko O, Ilmoniemi Risto J
Department of Neuroscience and Biomedical Engineering, Aalto University School of Science, P. O. Box 12200, FI-00076, Aalto, Espoo, Finland.
Department of Clinical Neurophysiology, Kuopio University Hospital, P. O. Box 100, FI-70029, Kuopio, Finland.
Brain Topogr. 2017 Nov;30(6):711-722. doi: 10.1007/s10548-017-0577-8. Epub 2017 Jul 18.
Navigated transcranial magnetic stimulation (nTMS) can be applied to locate and outline cortical motor representations. This may be important, e.g., when planning neurosurgery or focused nTMS therapy, or when assessing plastic changes during neurorehabilitation. Conventionally, a cortical location is considered to belong to the motor cortex if the maximum electric field (E-field) targeted there evokes a motor-evoked potential in a muscle. However, the cortex is affected by a broad E-field distribution, which tends to broaden estimates of representation areas by stimulating also the neighboring areas in addition to the maximum E-field location. Our aim was to improve the estimation of nTMS-based motor maps by taking into account the E-field distribution of the stimulation pulse. The effect of the E-field distribution was considered by calculating the minimum-norm estimate (MNE) of the motor representation area. We tested the method on simulated data and then applied it to recordings from six healthy volunteers and one stroke patient. We compared the motor representation areas obtained with the MNE method and a previously introduced interpolation method. The MNE hotspots and centers of gravity were close to those obtained with the interpolation method. The areas of the maps, however, depend on the thresholds used for outlining the areas. The MNE method may improve the definition of cortical motor areas, but its accuracy should be validated by comparing the results with maps obtained with direct cortical stimulation of the cortex where the E-field distribution can be better focused.
导航经颅磁刺激(nTMS)可用于定位和勾勒皮质运动表征。这可能很重要,例如在规划神经外科手术或聚焦nTMS治疗时,或在评估神经康复过程中的可塑性变化时。传统上,如果在某一位置靶向的最大电场(E场)能在肌肉中诱发运动诱发电位,则该皮质位置被认为属于运动皮质。然而,皮质会受到广泛的E场分布影响,除了最大E场位置外,还会刺激邻近区域,这往往会扩大表征区域的估计范围。我们的目的是通过考虑刺激脉冲的E场分布来改进基于nTMS的运动图谱估计。通过计算运动表征区域的最小范数估计(MNE)来考虑E场分布的影响。我们在模拟数据上测试了该方法,然后将其应用于六名健康志愿者和一名中风患者的记录。我们比较了用MNE方法和先前引入的插值方法获得的运动表征区域。MNE热点和重心与用插值方法获得的结果接近。然而,图谱的面积取决于用于勾勒区域的阈值。MNE方法可能会改善皮质运动区域的定义,但其准确性应通过将结果与通过对皮质进行直接皮质刺激获得的图谱进行比较来验证,在直接皮质刺激中E场分布可以更好地聚焦。