Entomology Division, Cocoa Research Institute of Ghana, New Tafo-Akim, Ghana.
African Regional Postgraduate Programme in Insect Science, University of Ghana, Legon, Accra, Ghana.
Environ Sci Pollut Res Int. 2017 Sep;24(26):21138-21145. doi: 10.1007/s11356-017-9737-3. Epub 2017 Jul 20.
Although evidence of mosquito coils' impact on disease epidemiology is limited, they are popularized as mosquito-borne disease prevention devices. Their usage affects the environment, human and mosquito health. This study investigated the perception, usage pattern and efficacy of coils in a predominantly poor malaria-endemic Ghanaian peri-urban area. Information on protection methods, perception and usage pattern was garnered using questionnaires. The efficacy of commonly used coils in the area was then assessed on the malaria vector, Anopheles gambiae, in a glass chamber. Sole or co-application of mosquito control methods and risky usage practices were reported. Coils were deemed harmful to humans and mosquitoes, and their perceived effectiveness varied, with several factors influencing their purchase. High d-allethrin concentration coils induced quicker mosquito knockdown; however, mortality was less than 85%. The coil usage pattern compromises users' health and can enhance mosquito tolerance to d-allethrin. The coils were ineffective against the vector, outlining a dichotomy between the users' perception of efficacy and the observed efficacy. Hence, the usage of other safer and more effective vector control methods should be encouraged to protect households.
尽管蚊香对疾病流行病学影响的证据有限,但它们被推广为预防蚊媒疾病的设备。它们的使用会影响环境、人类和蚊子的健康。本研究在加纳一个主要为贫困的疟疾流行城市郊区地区,调查了人们对蚊香的认知、使用模式和效果。通过问卷调查收集了关于保护方法、认知和使用模式的信息。然后,在一个玻璃室内评估了该地区常用蚊香对疟蚊 Anopheles gambiae 的效果。报告了单独或联合使用蚊虫控制方法和危险使用做法的情况。蚊香被认为对人类和蚊子都有害,人们对其效果的看法各不相同,有几个因素影响了他们的购买。高浓度 d-烯丙菊酯蚊香能更快地击倒蚊子,但死亡率低于 85%。蚊香的使用模式会损害使用者的健康,并能增强蚊子对 d-烯丙菊酯的耐受性。蚊香对该蚊媒无效,这表明使用者对效果的认知与实际观察到的效果之间存在差异。因此,应鼓励使用其他更安全、更有效的病媒控制方法来保护家庭。