Hussain Lahori Altaf, Zhang Zengqiang, Guo Zhanyu, Mahar Amanullah, Li Ronghua, Kumar Awasthi Mukesh, Ali Sial Tanveer, Kumbhar Farhana, Wang Ping, Shen Feng, Zhao Junchao, Huang Hui
College of Natural Resources and Environment, Northwest A&F University, Yangling, Shannxi 712100, China.
College of Natural Resources and Environment, Northwest A&F University, Yangling, Shannxi 712100, China.
Ecotoxicol Environ Saf. 2017 Nov;145:313-323. doi: 10.1016/j.ecoenv.2017.07.049. Epub 2017 Jul 27.
This explorative study was aimed to assess the efficiency of lime alone and in combined with additives to immobilize Pb, Cd, Cu and Zn in soil and reduce their phytoavailability for plant. A greenhouse pot experiment was performed by using low and heavily contaminated top soils viz. Tongguan contaminated (TG-C); Fengxian heavily contaminated (FX-HC) and Fengxian low contaminated (FX-LC). The contaminated soils were treated with lime (L) alone and in combined with Ca-bentonite (CB), Tobacco biochar (TB) and Zeolite (Z) at 1% and cultivated by Chinese cabbage (Brassica campestris L). Results revealed that all amendments (p< 0.05) significantly reduced the DTPA-extractable Pb 97.33, Cd 68.06 and Cu 91.11% with L+TB, L+CB, L+Z in FX-LC soil and Zn 87.12% respectively, with L+CB into TG-C soil. Consequently, the application of lime alone and in combined with additives were drastically decreased the dry biomass yield of Brassica campestris L. as compared with control. Thus, these feasible amendments potentially maximum reduced the uptake by plant shoots upto Pb 53.47 and Zn 67.93% with L+Z and L+TB in FX-LC soil, while Cd 68.58 and Cu 60.29% with L+TB, L+CB in TG-C soil but Cu uptake in plant shoot was observed 27.26% and 30.17% amended with L+TB and L+Z in FX-HC and FX-LC soils. On the other hand, these amendments were effectively reduced the potentially toxic metals (PTMs) in roots upto Pb77.77% L alone in FX-HC, Cd 96.76% with L+TB in TG-C, while, Cu 66.70 and Zn 60.18% with L+Z in FX-LC. Meanwhile, all amendments were responsible for increasing soil pH and CEC but decreased soils EC level. Based on this result, these feasible soil amendments were recommended for long term-study under field condition to see the response of another hyper accumulator crop.
本探索性研究旨在评估单独使用石灰以及石灰与添加剂组合对土壤中铅、镉、铜和锌的固定效果,并降低它们对植物的植物有效性。通过使用低污染和高污染的表层土壤进行了温室盆栽试验,即潼关污染土壤(TG-C)、凤县高污染土壤(FX-HC)和凤县低污染土壤(FX-LC)。将污染土壤分别单独用石灰(L)处理,以及与1%的钙基膨润土(CB)、烟草生物炭(TB)和沸石(Z)组合处理,然后种植小白菜(Brassica campestris L)。结果表明,所有改良剂(p<0.05)均显著降低了FX-LC土壤中DTPA可提取的铅97.33%、镉68.06%和铜91.11%(分别通过L+TB、L+CB、L+Z处理),以及TG-C土壤中锌87.12%(通过L+CB处理)。因此,与对照相比,单独使用石灰以及石灰与添加剂组合均大幅降低了小白菜的干生物量产量。因此,这些可行的改良剂在FX-LC土壤中,通过L+Z和L+TB处理,可使植物地上部对铅的吸收最多降低53.47%、对锌的吸收最多降低67.93%;在TG-C土壤中,通过L+TB、L+CB处理,可使植物地上部对镉的吸收降低68.58%、对铜的吸收降低60.29%,但在FX-HC和FX-LC土壤中,通过L+TB和L+Z处理,植物地上部对铜的吸收分别为27.26%和30.17%。另一方面,这些改良剂有效降低了根部的潜在有毒金属(PTMs),在FX-HC土壤中,单独使用L可使铅降低77.77%;在TG-C土壤中,L+TB可使镉降低96.76%;在FX-LC土壤中,L+Z可使铜降低66.70%、锌降低60.18%。同时,所有改良剂均使土壤pH值和阳离子交换量增加,但降低了土壤电导率水平。基于此结果,建议在田间条件下对这些可行的土壤改良剂进行长期研究,以观察另一种超富集作物的响应。