Veiga R V, Taylor R E
J Natl Med Assoc. 1986 Sep;78(9):851-6.
It has been reported that beta blockers are not effective antihypertensives in black populations. A review of the literature revealed that, for the most part, studies drawing this conclusion were of small sample size, lacked controls, and did not represent the demographics of the US black population. The largest US study (Veterans Administration Cooperative Study) showed propranolol to be effective in at least one half of the black patients, with white patients responding better, but diuretics were more effective in both races. More recent studies show beta blockers with alpha-antagonistic properties to be effective in black hypertensives. The question is raised whether enough data have been analyzed to suggest these drugs are ineffective for black hypertensives.
据报道,β受体阻滞剂对黑人人群并非有效的抗高血压药物。对文献的回顾显示,在很大程度上,得出这一结论的研究样本量小、缺乏对照,且不能代表美国黑人人群的人口统计学特征。美国规模最大的研究(退伍军人管理局合作研究)表明,普萘洛尔至少对一半的黑人患者有效,白人患者的反应更好,但利尿剂对两个种族的患者都更有效。最近的研究表明,具有α拮抗特性的β受体阻滞剂对黑人高血压患者有效。有人提出疑问,是否已经分析了足够的数据来表明这些药物对黑人高血压患者无效。