Salvo John P, Zarah Jake, Chaudhry Zaira S, Poehling-Monaghan Kirsten L
Rothman Institute at Thomas Jefferson University, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA.
Orthop J Sports Med. 2017 Jul 21;5(7):2325967117719014. doi: 10.1177/2325967117719014. eCollection 2017 Jul.
The frequency of hip arthroscopy for the treatment of acute and chronic chondrolabral pathology and femoroacetabular impingement (FAI) has increased exponentially over the past decade. While surgeon and patient radiation exposure has been well documented in other areas of the orthopaedic literature, little is known about the procedure-specific and cumulative doses affecting the hip arthroscopist.
To determine the mean annual radiation exposure to the hip arthroscopist and the mean surgeon exposure per case.
Case series; Level of evidence, 4.
A total of 210 consecutive hip arthroscopies performed in 209 patients by a single surgeon at a single ambulatory surgical center in a cohort consisting of approximately 50% bony (cam and pincer) pathology were prospectively reviewed, documenting the specific procedures performed in each case and the readings from a radiation dosimeter worn by the surgeon during positioning and while performing the procedures. Radiation readings for deep dose-equivalent (DDE), lens dose-equivalent (LDE), and shallow dose-equivalent (SDE) were measured. These readings were compared with the annual radiation dose limit recommendations established by the International Commission on Radiological Protection (ICRP).
The total radiation doses for the operative surgeon during all 210 cases were 183 mrem (1.83 mSv) DDE, 183 mrem (1.83 mSv) LDE, and 176 mrem (1.76 mSv) SDE. The mean exposure per case was 0.871 mrem (0.00871 mSv) DDE, 0.871 mrem (0.00871 mSv) LDE, and 0.838 mrem (0.00838 mSv) SDE. The operative surgeon's mean annual exposure, performing 70 hip arthroscopies per year with 55% involving bony work, was 61.0 mrem (0.610 mSv) DDE, 61.0 mrem (0.610 mSv) LDE, and 58.7 mrem (0.587 mSv) SDE. These results are well below the ICRP annual limits of 50,000 mrem (500 mSv) DDE, 2000 mrem (20 mSv) LDE, and 50,000 mrem (500 mSv) SDE.
For an experienced hip arthroscopist utilizing fluoroscopy during setup and bony resection, the annual and per-patient exposure to radiation remains well below the recommended ICRP limits.
Considering the increasing annual frequency of hip arthroscopies being performed, information regarding procedure-specific and cumulative doses of radiation exposure affecting the hip arthroscopist may provide valuable safety information for the orthopaedic community.
在过去十年中,用于治疗急慢性髋臼盂唇病变和股骨髋臼撞击症(FAI)的髋关节镜检查频率呈指数级增长。虽然在骨科文献的其他领域,外科医生和患者的辐射暴露情况已有充分记录,但对于影响髋关节镜医生的特定手术和累积剂量却知之甚少。
确定髋关节镜医生的年均辐射暴露量以及每例手术中医师的平均暴露量。
病例系列;证据等级,4级。
在一个门诊手术中心,由一名外科医生对209例患者连续进行了210例髋关节镜检查,前瞻性地回顾了该队列,其中约50%为骨性(凸轮型和钳夹型)病变,记录了每例手术所执行的具体操作以及外科医生在定位和手术过程中佩戴的辐射剂量计的读数。测量了深部剂量当量(DDE)、晶状体剂量当量(LDE)和浅表剂量当量(SDE)的辐射读数。将这些读数与国际放射防护委员会(ICRP)制定的年度辐射剂量限值建议进行比较。
在所有210例手术中,手术医生的总辐射剂量分别为:DDE为183毫雷姆(1.83毫希沃特),LDE为183毫雷姆(1.83毫希沃特),SDE为176毫雷姆(1.76毫希沃特)。每例手术的平均暴露量分别为:DDE为0.871毫雷姆(0.00871毫希沃特),LDE为0.871毫雷姆(0.00871毫希沃特),SDE为0.838毫雷姆(0.00838毫希沃特)。该手术医生每年平均进行70例髋关节镜检查,其中55%涉及骨性操作,其年均暴露量分别为:DDE为61.0毫雷姆(0.610毫希沃特),LDE为61.0毫雷姆(0.610毫希沃特),SDE为58.7毫雷姆(0.587毫希沃特)。这些结果远低于ICRP的年度限值,即DDE为50000毫雷姆(500毫希沃特),LDE为2000毫雷姆(20毫希沃特),SDE为50000毫雷姆(500毫希沃特)。
对于在手术设置和骨切除过程中使用透视的经验丰富的髋关节镜医生,其年度和每例患者的辐射暴露量仍远低于ICRP推荐的限值。
考虑到每年进行的髋关节镜检查频率不断增加,关于影响髋关节镜医生的特定手术和累积辐射剂量的信息可能为骨科界提供有价值的安全信息。