Song Jihye, Park Jung Eon, Chung Joonho, Lim Yong Chul, Shin Yong Sam
Department of Neurosurgery, Konyang College of Medicine, Konyang University Hospital, Daejeon, Republic of Korea.
Department of Neurosurgery, Hankook Hospital, Cheongju, Republic of Korea.
Surg Neurol Int. 2017 Jul 25;8:155. doi: 10.4103/sni.sni_132_16. eCollection 2017.
The aim of this study was to evaluate the clinical outcomes between endovascular treatment (EVT) and surgery of the ruptured posterior inferior cerebellar artery (PICA) aneurysms and suggest proper management strategies according to the PICA segment.
We retrospectively analyzed clinical and radiological data of patients with ruptured PICA aneurysms who underwent surgery or EVT from three different institutes. Clinical outcomes were evaluated by mRS.
We collected 39 consecutive patients with 39 ruptured PICA aneurysms; 26 patients were with proximal segment aneurysm and 13 patients were with distal. Of the 26 proximal PICA aneurysms, 20 aneurysms were treated with EVT and 6 aneurysms were treated with surgery. EVT seemed to have more favorable clinical outcome (mRS 0-2; mean mRS, 1.75 for EVT vs 3.50 for surgery, = 0.152). Of the 13 distal PICA aneurysms, 7 aneurysms were treated with EVT and 6 were treated with surgery. Surgery showed more favorable clinical outcome (mean mRS, 2.63 for EVT vs 0.33 for surgery, = 0.023) and lower procedure-related complication rate (42.9% for EVT vs 0% for surgery, = 0.046) than EVT.
For the treatment of ruptured PICA aneurysms, EVT seemed to have more favorable outcomes for proximal segment, while surgery showed more favorable outcomes for distal segment. Additional experience and follow-up are needed in a larger series to state the efficacy of this strategy.
本研究旨在评估破裂的小脑后下动脉(PICA)动脉瘤的血管内治疗(EVT)与手术治疗的临床结果,并根据PICA节段提出适当的治疗策略。
我们回顾性分析了来自三个不同机构接受手术或EVT治疗的破裂PICA动脉瘤患者的临床和放射学数据。临床结果采用改良Rankin量表(mRS)进行评估。
我们连续收集了39例患有39个破裂PICA动脉瘤的患者;26例患者为近端节段动脉瘤,13例患者为远端节段动脉瘤。在26个近端PICA动脉瘤中,20个动脉瘤接受了EVT治疗,6个动脉瘤接受了手术治疗。EVT似乎具有更有利的临床结果(mRS 0-2;EVT的平均mRS为1.75,手术为3.50,P = 0.152)。在13个远端PICA动脉瘤中,7个动脉瘤接受了EVT治疗,6个接受了手术治疗。手术显示出更有利的临床结果(EVT的平均mRS为2.63,手术为0.33,P = 0.023),且与手术相关的并发症发生率低于EVT(EVT为42.9%,手术为0%,P = 0.046)。
对于破裂PICA动脉瘤的治疗,EVT似乎对近端节段有更有利的结果,而手术对远端节段有更有利的结果。需要更多的经验和更大样本量的随访来阐明该策略的疗效。