Naz Hafeeza, Mushtaq Kinza, Butt Bilal Azeem, Khawaja Khadija Irfan
Dr. Hafeeza Naz, FCPS. Department of Endocrinology and Metabolism, Services Hospital/SIMS Lahore, Pakistan.
Dr. Kinza Mushtaq, MBBS. Department of Endocrinology and Metabolism, Services Hospital/SIMS Lahore, Pakistan.
Pak J Med Sci. 2017 May-Jun;33(3):635-639. doi: 10.12669/pjms.333.12806.
To compare three different body fats estimation equations using skin fold measurements with bioelectrical impedance analysis.
A total of 130 subjects were included from Department of Endocrinology and Metabolism, Services Hospital, Lahore from 1 April 2016 to 30 Sep. 2016. The triceps, biceps, subscapular, chest, thigh, abdominal, suprailiac skinfold thickness of the subjects was measured with skin-fold calipers (Harpenden) on non-dominant side. The percentage fat mass (%FM) predicted by using each skin-fold-thickness equations namely Durnin & Womersley, Jackson & Pollock and Sloan was compared with %FM measured using a bioelectrical impedance analyzer (BIA).
The mean age of subjects was 48.75±10.7 years, mean BMI was 29.08±6.09 kg/m. The mean %FM calculated by Durnin & Womersley (32.408±0.584), Jackson & Pollock (24.658±0.527), Sloan (20.40±0.545). The %FM by BIA was 38.182±0.529. All three equations showed positive correlation but underestimated %FM as compared to BIA.
All three BF estimation equations underestimate body fat percentage compared to BIA. Among the three, Durnin & Womersley equation shows best positive correlation and hence it can be used for estimation of percentage fat mass as an alternate to BIA.
比较三种不同的利用皮褶测量与生物电阻抗分析来估算体脂的方程。
2016年4月1日至2016年9月30日期间,从拉合尔服务医院内分泌与代谢科纳入了总共130名受试者。使用皮褶卡尺(哈彭登式)在非优势侧测量受试者的肱三头肌、肱二头肌、肩胛下、胸部、大腿、腹部、髂上皮肤褶厚度。将使用每个皮褶厚度方程(即杜宁与沃姆斯利方程、杰克逊与波洛克方程和斯隆方程)预测的脂肪量百分比(%FM)与使用生物电阻抗分析仪(BIA)测量的%FM进行比较。
受试者的平均年龄为48.75±10.7岁,平均体重指数为29.08±6.09kg/m²。杜宁与沃姆斯利方程计算的平均%FM为(32.408±0.584),杰克逊与波洛克方程为(24.658±0.527),斯隆方程为(20.40±0.545)。BIA测量的%FM为38.182±0.529。所有三个方程均显示出正相关性,但与BIA相比,均低估了%FM。
与BIA相比,所有三个体脂估算方程均低估了体脂百分比。在这三个方程中,杜宁与沃姆斯利方程显示出最佳的正相关性,因此它可作为BIA的替代方法用于估算脂肪量百分比。