Nõu E
Scand J Respir Dis Suppl. 1979;104:83-106.
Forty-eight bronchial carcinoma patients in clinicoanatomical stage 4 of the disease (advanced disease) were randomly assigned to groups for radiotherapy, chemotherapy (cyclophosphamide) and placebo treatment, respectively. The results were assessed by the survival time and quality of survival. The median survival time was 4.7 months for radiotherapy, 4.7 months for cyclophosphamide and 1.7 months for placebo. The median total sum of vitagram points was 28.1 for radiotherapy, 20.7 for cyclophosphamide and 6.8 for placebo. When calculated per month, the median sum of vitagram points was 5.9 for radiotherapy, 5.7 for cyclophosphamide and 4.8 for placebo. Statistically the results give no reason to believe that placebo is better than radiotherapy, but it cannot be excluded that radiotherapy patients could have a much longer survival. As for cyclophosphamide versus radiotherapy, the differences are to uncertain for any conclusion to be drawn.
48例处于临床解剖学4期(晚期)的支气管癌患者被随机分为放疗组、化疗(环磷酰胺)组和安慰剂治疗组。通过生存时间和生存质量对结果进行评估。放疗组的中位生存时间为4.7个月,环磷酰胺组为4.7个月,安慰剂组为1.7个月。活力图表积分总和的中位数,放疗组为28.1,环磷酰胺组为20.7,安慰剂组为6.8。按每月计算,活力图表积分的中位数,放疗组为5.9,环磷酰胺组为5.7,安慰剂组为4.8。从统计学角度来看,结果没有理由让人相信安慰剂比放疗效果更好,但不能排除放疗患者的生存期可能长得多的情况。至于环磷酰胺与放疗的比较,差异尚不确定,无法得出任何结论。