Poushay Heather M, Kagedan Daniel J, Hallet Julie, Conn Lesley Gotlib, Beyfuss Kaitlyn, Nadler Ashlie, Ahmed Najma, Wright Frances C
Division of General Surgery, Department of Surgery, University of Toronto, Toronto, ON, Canada.
Division of General Surgery, Sunnybrook Health Sciences Centre, Toronto, ON, Canada.
Ann Surg. 2018 Jan;267(1):e4-e5. doi: 10.1097/SLA.0000000000002467.
: Limited recent data exist regarding intended retirement plans for general surgeons (GS). We sought to understand when and why surgeons decide to stop operating as primary surgeon and stop all clinical work.A paper-based survey of practicing GS in the province of Ontario, Canada, was conducted. A questionnaire was developed using a systematic approach of item generation and reduction. Face and content validity were tested. The survey was administered via mail, with a planned reminder.Overall response rate was 33.5% (242/723). The median age at which respondents planned to/did stop operating was 65 (interquartile range 60-67.5). The median age at which respondents planned to/did retire from all clinical work was 70 (interquartile range 65-72.5). Career satisfaction (97%), sense of identity (90%), and financial need (69%) were factors that influenced the decision to continue operating. Enjoyment of work (79%), camaraderie with surgical colleagues (66%), and financial need (45%) were reasons to continue working after ceasing to operate as the primary surgeon. On multivariate analysis, younger respondents (36-50 years old) perceived they were less likely to continue operating past age 65 (odds ratio 0.13), and academic surgeons were more likely to stop operating after age 65 (odds ratio 2.39). Call coverage by nonstaff surgeons was not associated with retirement age.Overall, GS plan to stop operating at age 65, and to cease all clinical activities at age 70. Younger, nonacademic surgeons plan to stop operating earlier. Career satisfaction, sense of identity, and financial need are the principal reported motivations to continue operating.
关于普通外科医生(GS)的预期退休计划,近期数据有限。我们试图了解外科医生何时以及为何决定不再担任主刀医生并停止所有临床工作。
对加拿大安大略省执业的普通外科医生进行了一项纸质问卷调查。通过系统的项目生成和简化方法制定了一份问卷。测试了表面效度和内容效度。该调查通过邮寄方式进行,并计划发送提醒。
总体回复率为33.5%(242/723)。受访者计划停止/实际停止手术的中位年龄为65岁(四分位间距60 - 67.5岁)。受访者计划从所有临床工作中退休/实际退休的中位年龄为70岁(四分位间距65 - 72.5岁)。职业满意度(97%)、身份认同感(90%)和经济需求(69%)是影响继续手术决定的因素。工作乐趣(79%)、与外科同事的情谊(66%)和经济需求(45%)是在不再担任主刀医生后继续工作的原因。多因素分析显示,年轻受访者(36 - 50岁)认为他们在65岁之后继续手术的可能性较小(优势比0.13),而学术外科医生在65岁之后更有可能停止手术(优势比2.39)。非在职外科医生的值班覆盖情况与退休年龄无关。
总体而言,普通外科医生计划在65岁时停止手术,并在70岁时停止所有临床活动。年轻的非学术外科医生计划更早停止手术。职业满意度、身份认同感和经济需求是报告的继续手术的主要动机。